5 ms·
>a very naive view of some basic economic concepts. Which concepts in particular are you referring to?
by wyager 12y ago
>a very naive view of some basic economic concepts.
Which concepts in particular are you referring to?
- shiven 12y agoThe failure, nay the pigheaded refusal, to learn from history. BitCoin is faux money and will likely be recorded as the "Dutch Tulip Bubble" [0] of our times. Intentions and wishful thinking alone are not enough to create revolutions. Crises are invariably required to change such fundamental concepts as value of currency in the public's mind, and it has to happen on a massive scale in a tiny span of time. BitCoin will be no more than the butt of jokes in another decade unless it finds it's destiny in a crisis made for it to shine. [0] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania
- wyager 12y agoYou haven't actually mentioned any economic principles; you've just compared Bitcoin to a historical bubble (of which there were certainly many) without any evidence supporting this comparison. >BitCoin is faux money Could you expand on this? How do you define "faux" money?
- ougawouga 12y agoOK, you're making 2 different claims. The first claim is that Bitoiners refuse to learn from history. But the second claim is that crises are required for revolutionary change (history says, I presume). So how are Bitcoiners refusing to learn from history? By trying in the first place? Or by failing to manufacture a crisis? And really, linking to the wikipedia page of tulip mania, as if we haven't heard that trope 10,000 times?
- mbesto 12y agoFor one, there's a massive disconnect in distinguishing between the value of the currency and currency as a medium of exchange. For example, most sites and discussions focus on the value of BTC vs USD. Very few look at volatility and transaction volume.
- wyager 12y ago>Very few look at volatility That is fair. Do you think this is an insurmountable disadvantage? >and transaction volume. I don't know about that. Bitcoiners have been very vocal about the regularly increasing transaction volume since its inception. See https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions-excluding-popular?timespan=all https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions-excluding-popu...
- jevgeni 12y agoUsing Bitcoin is basically, like using a foreign currency, with the only difference, that in case of a the conventional currency you might actually live in the country it is used. In other words, whenever you use Bitcoin you take on FX risk. This means, that Bitcoin is something you wouldn't want to store value in for the long-term. Hedging that risk will also prove a major headache, since there aren't that many Bitcoin contracts out there, and the ones that are, carry some major credit risk with them.
- furbyhater 12y agoIt's different than most other foreign currencies in the sense that it's variance in value is MUCH higher than your usual currency. I would consider storing my personal fortune in CHF, JPY, USD, or even EUR but never in BTC.
- jevgeni 12y agoExactly, the volatility is why people wouldn't use it as a store of value. P. S. I like how you went "...or even EUR" ;)
- wyager 12y ago>This means, that Bitcoin is something you wouldn't want to store value in for the long-term. I can think of a reason you would want to. Bitcoin is strictly supply-limited, and all fiat currencies are not. One might decide that, despite Bitcoin's volatility, the expected change in unit value over time is higher than that of any (inflationary) fiat currency.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoFriction, lowest friction tends to win and bitcoin demands friction to run the blockchain. I don't think electronic exchange mechanisms are daft, but I do think the bitcoin model is.
- wyager 12y ago>bitcoin demands friction to run the blockchain It requires (electrical) power. I don't think this could reasonably be called "friction". When I think "friction", I think of burdens imposed on users. Bitcoin has relatively few of those.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoCost per transaction of $19 is a fair amount of friction - https://blockchain.info/charts/cost-per-transaction https://blockchain.info/charts/cost-per-transaction
- wyager 12y ago>Cost per transaction of $19 is a fair amount of friction Haha, I have no idea what that chart is talking about. It might be in cents. Even then, it seems expensive. My phone client uses a ~$0.05 fee, I think. All fees are optional. Your transaction might just take longer without one.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoYeah, just thinking about that fee graph. I have no idea of the transaction size it is based on and without that it is pretty useless.
- backdraw_ 12y agoThere are about 500 transactions per block; each block contains 25BTC + fees (the fees are negligible at the moment). At the current price of $350/BTC that means that the revenue per transaction is 25*350/500 = $17, which means that the cost per transaction should be around that area. This means that the low transaction fee is actually massively subsidized by the fixed block reward.