4 ms·
This is understandable, you don't like people to think bad things about you. But what if they don't comply and still do? What if they somehow would still rememb
by smsm42 12y ago
This is understandable, you don't like people to think bad things about you. But what if they don't comply and still do? What if they somehow would still remember "ah, this is the guy who 2 years ago... etc."? What if they keep records, archives, talk to each other, share their views, memories, write books, memoirs, etc.? That would be a problem. The only solution I see is to ban the concept of recording of the past, the records and the memory altogether, at least where it concerns matters that can upset somebody. If you want everybody to forget you got drunk and embarrassed yourself 2 years ago, they must do so. If they have photos, they must delete them. If they have recorded it in their journals, they must destroy them. If they talked about it - they must stop talking. If they have memories, they must forget - or at least never speak about it again. Understandable, this could be a bit of a PITA to organize and keep track of, but isn't it a worthy goal - everybody then would be able to do shit and no long-term consequences would ever follow!
- vidarh 12y agoOr, you know, you take the pragmatic approach of allowing limited removal from search indexes so that recall is a bit harder. The court very specifically did not order removal from primary sources.
- smsm42 12y agoHow is it pragmatic? You don't hide the info, so it is still available to anyone interested, and if the interest is enough, there would be services allowing to retrieve the same info. If the interest is so low it can not support such services, there's no practical point in this system anyway, since it would be targeting a problem that barely exists. So you'd have to either ban any access to such information or engage in pointless regulation for the sake of "doing something", while achieving no result. Not that governments are strangers to such modus operandi - a lot of regulations, from War on Drugs to numerous others are proven completely useless for the purpose they are trying to achieve yet persist for decades under the guise of "if we only try a bit harder, this time surely it will work!". It won't.