5 ms·
If I may critique his critique, changing one single assumption completely changes the story. He starts with the assumption of 100dB as the max power but OSHA's
by mikeyouse 12y ago
If I may critique his critique, changing one single assumption completely changes the story. He starts with the assumption of 100dB as the max power but OSHA's ultrasonic recommendation[1] is actually 145dB which is 31,000x more power.. Even if you use 130dB, it's still 1,000x more power than he assumes.
Another big assumption is that the performance should match a 5W iPhone charger. Why? The whole point is at you won't need to worry about charging. If you have 8 hours at your desk to charge rather than 20 minutes plugged in, you can get by charging at 1/20th the speed.
So try putting a requirement of 0.25W and 130dB in his formulas and see if you'd 'gamble' $10M on this idea... I'm on mobile so excuse the lack of units, but I followed his calcs for a 25cm x 25cm transmitter at 130dB:
http://m.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=10+*+%284pi%29+*+.25%5E2+*+50%25&x=0&y=0 http://m.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=10+*+%284pi%29+*+.25%5E2+...
So it should deliver ~4W. Obviously there will be losses, etc but even at 25%, 1W should be sufficient to passively charge your phone.
Note that all of the same assumptions but with 140dB would instead give you 10W, which is only slightly less than the rapid charger for the new iPads.
[1] - https://www.osha.gov/dts/osta/otm/noise/health_effects/ultrasonics.html https://www.osha.gov/dts/osta/otm/noise/health_effects/ultra...
- sharpneli 12y agoAt 130 and 140dB air is starting to behave rather nonlinearly. That means you will actually start hearing it. Remember that the OSHA ultrasonic recommendation is more about "Will it permanently harm you" than comfort. At 140dB you'd hear probably rather substantial audible whine due to first and second order harmonics. On the other hand a brutal whine at 15kHz is perfect for keeping those kids off my lawn when I charge my phone! Edit: I tried to find some information about the receiving end transducer losses. I bet they're going to be insane as it basically any impedance mismatch with air is going to cause the power to just reflect away, the bigger the mismatch the bigger the wasted power.
- cowsandmilk 12y agoactually, for 20 kHZ, the frequency in his article, the OSHA recommendation is 105dB. And if you dig into the OSHA regs, the 115+30 standard for higher frequencies only applies for 15 minutes of exposure per day or less. So, if you only want your charger running for 15 minutes, have at it!
- mikeyouse 12y agoAgain, why 20 kHz? The patent application only lists examples of greater than 40kHz -- most are in the range of 50+ kHz. My point isn't that this tech is going to work and change the world just that it's incredibly easy to be pessimistic and to justify it with small incorrect assumptions.
- jschwartzi 12y agoAlso, sound levels below OSHA limits can still be uncomfortably loud. They just won't do any permanent damage.