3 ms·
While evolution is true, it doesn't explain the most interesting aspects of life -- namely, consciousness and (apparent) free will. This is an enormous gap in
by amichail 17y ago
While evolution is true, it doesn't explain the most interesting aspects of life -- namely, consciousness and (apparent) free will.
This is an enormous gap in understanding and it would be nice if Dawkins were to acknowledge this more in his talks. Evolution doesn't really explain life.
- emmett 17y agoYet.
- jsankey 17y agoBingo. Science doesn't have all the answers: but it can admit when it doesn't (contrast with faith). Dawkins does speak of consciousness in his work, and admits to not having a full explanation. Criticising what has been explained so far on the basis that we don't yet know everything is analogous to pointing out gaps in the fossil record.
- nobody_nowhere 17y agoIsn't that like saying "while e=mc^2 is true, it doesn't explain music"?
- netsp 17y agoYes. It is very similar, but a little worse because evolution does play an role in understanding interesting aspects of life like art, morality and love.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- netsp 17y agoThis is just silly belittling. It doesn't really mean anything. What do you mean by "life?" It doesn't tell you what you should do with it? The reason evolution ever became such a important part of atheism is because it weakens the historically strongest argument for believing in god: The 'How could all this just happen?' question. Evolution gives you a good answer to the most common version of that question (the flowers and the trees and the deer and you, little Janet). It's still in use with the beginning of life of physics or other things as an illustration, but the most powerful example is now gone. Also, it gives you a clue that many such processes exist.
- unalone 17y agoPerhaps life has no explanation. Perhaps the fact that every person who tries to understand life reaches a different "answer" implies that life is life to be life, and that any other meaning is personal in nature. Evolution is describing something objective—it describes how something happens. You're looking for the subjective realm of philosophy.
- amichail 17y agoConsciousness is a real phenomenon. Although it is a subjective experience, the fact that it exists is entirely objective.
- gloob 17y agoThe fact that a single, first-person consciousness exists is entirely objective. To the best of my knowledge, there is no scientific way to go about verifying the consciousness of others; despite this (and despite the traditional "lack of evidence is evidence of lack" bent of Popperian science), most people work from a default assumption that other people have an existence somewhat similar to their own.
- maxwell 17y ago> The fact that a single, first-person consciousness exists is entirely objective. I wouldn't describe my consciousness as 'single or 'first-person. It often runs multiple threads, and by no means exclusively thinks of itself in the first-person. Additionally, it really doesn't identify with this body much more than, say, this house or computer. My consciousness isn't 'human any more than it's "ranch-style" or 'x86. Our language has already adopted inorganic technologies as extensions of ourselves (e.g. I say "I'll come over" which expands to "I'll come over in my car").
- tome 17y agoYou might be interested in Thomas Nagel's "What is it like to be a bat?" which takes the opposite stance to you, i.e. that bat consciousness is inseparable from being a bat (and analogously, human). See e.g. http://www.consciousentities.com/bats.htm http://www.consciousentities.com/bats.htm