2 ms·
There are basically two approaches to designing things on the Internet. One is where you pay attention to what your users want and find ways to satisfy those ne
by wpietri 12y ago
There are basically two approaches to designing things on the Internet. One is where you pay attention to what your users want and find ways to satisfy those needs. The other is to run around shouting NO NO NO YOU'RE DOING IT WRONG and whacking the users on the nose with a newspaper any time the do something other than you intended.
Both sorts of approaches can work; Stack Exchange is decently successful. But I find the latter hopelessly arrogant. An example is Friendster, the social networking site that preceded MySpace and Facebook. The founder wanted something where he could get dates, so that's what he built. When people started creating identities for non-people things (bands, movies, places, groups, political parties) they could have said, "Hey, look, our users are trying to tell us something. Let's built those features right!" Instead, they ran around with the banstick trying to force everybody back to the intended behavior. That worked until MySpace and Facebook came along, and now people barely remember Friendster.
Stack Overflow could have created features that channeled the "let's talk about interesting things" energy properly. It would have served their community well, and it would have given them more eyeballs on things that are questions with definite answers. Instead, they've been unrepentant dicks about it and have driven many people away.