3 ms·
I am genuinely interested in knowing how we go from here to there. Alcohol for example after prohibition - what was the transition from illegal to legal like.
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
I am genuinely interested in knowing how we go from here to there. Alcohol for example after prohibition - what was the transition from illegal to legal like. Did more people drink suddenly? What organisations sprang up to legally manufacture and distribute? Where the mafia still involved?
Saying "decriminalise" is all good - but if at any point in the supply chain we dip into the underground market we shall not escape the violence and control of crime. So are there plans for movin from prohibition to open market?
- drdeca 12y agoOne idea that I have not thought through well, and don't know what the consequences would be, would be to instead of possession of sale of the drugs being illegal, making it so that, for some collection of other crimes, if the crime was committed in a way related to the drug, the penalty for the crime would be greater. The idea I was thinking is that this would create a disincentive to have the crimes and the drugs related, and might cut down on "drug crime" more than just removing the ban on the drugs? I believe I've seen some say that even where a drug is legalize, there still remains a black market for that drug in that situation in order to avoid taxes on that drug. If tax avoidance had a greater fine if caught if money from (non medicinal) drugs was involved, would that perhaps discourage sellers from not paying taxes on the income, and as a result reducing the black market type stuff? I don't know. I am not saying that I support this idea, its just an idea I thought was interesting. I don't know what one would reasonably/realistically expect the results to be. Does anyone have any ideas as to what results would result from such a law?
- aidos 12y agoCountries, like Portugal have had a lot of success with just changing the issue from a criminal issue to a health issue with regard to possession. If you're caught with quantities that imply you're dealing you still end up in trouble. I'd imagine that if you allowed sanctioned selling of drugs you'd create a fair market and crime around it would quickly vanish. Unfortunately we live in a world where we may never see an experiment like that come to fruition.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]