6 ms·
The Angry Evolutionist
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago>It would be so nice if those who oppose evolution would take a tiny bit of trouble to learn the merest rudiments of what it is that they are opposing. Sigh. This depresses me more than anything else about the creationists I've met: the stubborn, aggressive, unapologetic ignorance in which they happily cloak themselves.
- callmeed 17y agoTrust me, it depresses some creationists too.
- netsp 17y agoWhich ones?
- jmtulloss 17y agoProbably those that don't deny evolution. I think they are more the "intelligent design" camp. I'm not terribly familiar with what the labels mean.
- netsp 17y agoIntelligent design, as far as I understand, argues that there is (must be) a conscious and deliberate designer. It doesn't specify who. Most evolutionists think that intelligent design is a creationist conspiracy to teach creationism under a different name and re-branded as a scientific theory. It is usually presented as a conflicting theory.
- pushingbits 17y agoI'd say it's more like cognitive dissonance on the part of educated creationists. They have to reconcile the fact that they live in the modern world with the fact that they believe in something that has no place in it.
- netsp 17y agoI don't see a flood of educated creationists embracing intelligent design in its common forms.
- pushingbits 17y agoNo? In my experience intelligent design proponents tend to be better educated than plain old creationists. Moreover in environments where most people embrace science, you are much more likely to find an IDer than a creationist. Intelligent design makes it possible for people to keep their crufty notions without feeling like troglodytes. But since it really is just a slim veneer of jingoist science, on some level they still feel insecure about it, which is why they need official institutions to recognize it. Of course there some people who consciously use intelligent design to get creationism back into the classroom, but I don't think that the majority of people who subscribe to it are so calculating. Never ascribe to malice what can be adequately explained by psychology.
- netsp 17y agoNow I'm curious. Are there any real biologists promoting this?
- jballanc 17y agoMore than just think, we know that it's a conspiracy, and we have the proof: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wedge_document http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wedge_document
- netsp 17y agoMaybe you know. I suspect. Don't "we" me! Thanks for the link though.
- jballanc 17y ago"We" know insomuch as the Discovery Institute wrote a document setting forth Intelligent Design as a method to do an end-run around the establishment clause and get Creationism into the classroom, and then later admitted that they wrote that document. What's left to suspect?
- tome 17y agoThe theory may not specify the designer, but I'd be impressed if you can find me one person who supports intelligent design, who does not have a personal belief about who that designer is.
- Dobbs 17y agoDepends on how you define "personal belief" because Deists believe in a "Intelligent Design" (The non-conspiracy version), but have a very lose definition of what god is or isn't.
- dasil003 17y agoThis also reminds me of a steady trend in politics over the last 40 years. Increased partisanship has led to more and more politicians and even supposed journalists resorting to mining sound bites and even in some cases completely fabricating attacks just to bring the other side down and prevent them from accomplishing anything. The way the talk radio hosts and other right wing extremists control large swaths of the population with blatant lies is horrifying. The really disturbing thing is the intractability of this sort of willful ignorance.
- chrischen 17y ago>It would be so nice if those who oppose evolution would take a tiny bit of trouble to learn the merest rudiments of what it is that they are opposing. Those who oppose evolution do so because they want to, not because they haven't been enlightened. People extend faith into God because they want to, not because all evidence suggests he exists. They may learn it, but they'll probably still oppose it.
- amichail 17y agoWhile evolution is true, it doesn't explain the most interesting aspects of life -- namely, consciousness and (apparent) free will. This is an enormous gap in understanding and it would be nice if Dawkins were to acknowledge this more in his talks. Evolution doesn't really explain life.
- emmett 17y agoYet.
- jsankey 17y agoBingo. Science doesn't have all the answers: but it can admit when it doesn't (contrast with faith). Dawkins does speak of consciousness in his work, and admits to not having a full explanation. Criticising what has been explained so far on the basis that we don't yet know everything is analogous to pointing out gaps in the fossil record.
- nobody_nowhere 17y agoIsn't that like saying "while e=mc^2 is true, it doesn't explain music"?
- netsp 17y agoYes. It is very similar, but a little worse because evolution does play an role in understanding interesting aspects of life like art, morality and love.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- netsp 17y agoThis is just silly belittling. It doesn't really mean anything. What do you mean by "life?" It doesn't tell you what you should do with it? The reason evolution ever became such a important part of atheism is because it weakens the historically strongest argument for believing in god: The 'How could all this just happen?' question. Evolution gives you a good answer to the most common version of that question (the flowers and the trees and the deer and you, little Janet). It's still in use with the beginning of life of physics or other things as an illustration, but the most powerful example is now gone. Also, it gives you a clue that many such processes exist.
- jswinghammer 17y agoI always wonder why people care so much about this. There isn't a good reason why this would ever matter to someone. If your case is strong make it and move on. Most people don't have sufficient background in science to understand much of physics or math these days but no one really gets mad about that. The truth is the truth and it settles itself in the end. I'm yet to hear of a single chair of a biology department of any major university who doesn't agree with contemporary evolutionary theory and people in the US have doubted evolution since it was first introduced. There isn't some looming threat to science and no one needs to get so upset about this. I'm a follower of Jesus who believes in angels but I don't have a super strong belief about evolution either way. I'll probably teach evolution to my kids who I plan on homeschooling and encourage them to consider how this might fit with a world view that includes God. Believing or not believing in evolution is just not a central issue to most people following Jesus. I've never met anyone who this is a big issue for. I guess they're out there but it's never really seemed like this massive issue for people.
- amichail 17y agoEvolution and Christianity are in conflict in the sense that it is possible but unlikely that evolution went through a bottleneck where Adam and Eve were the first two humans and all other humans are their descendents. This makes the concept of original sin problematic -- and thus introduces a problem with Christianity.
- jswinghammer 17y agoUnless that's not a literal description but rather a story that demonstrates that our parents rebelled against God and now we're under their curse.
- albemuth 17y agoAlmost any religious belief can be spun in a way so that believers stop questioning their faith.
- 17y ago
- brisance 17y agoThe fact that we share so much of our genetic code with other animals shows that we are linked in some way.
- amichail 17y agoThis doesn't follow since in a creationist view it is possible that the more similar the animals, the more similar their DNA. However, one can make a very strong argument for evolution by looking at non-functional parts of DNA. For example, our DNA contains a program for producing vitamin C but it doesn't work. A similar program in other animals does work.
- JBiserkov 17y agoor that God knew all about code reuse...
- jmtulloss 17y agoWe certainly could learn a lot about robust software design from studying how biological systems work.
- modelic3 17y agoDawkins is awesome. The man cares enough to educate and debunk myths. I wish all academics had such passion and devotions to their craft.
- chrischen 17y agoBelieving in angels and believing in evolution evolution are not mutually exclusive. The statement is misleading. Most people believe in evolution, not creationism. Those who do believe in creationism have detached themselves from logic and reality, so there's no point in arguing with them.
- davidw 17y agoThis is one of those debates/issues that is not going to be solved on HN, is more likely to generate heat than light, and thus is probably more appropriate for some other forum.
- jonny_noog 17y agoTo be clear, I am squarely on Dawkins's side, I am not a Creationist, or a follower of any religion. What Dawkins is saying makes perfect sense to me. Having said that, I have often found it curious the number of times I have seen Dawkins interviewed or read his writings, he does tend to talk down to his foes or use a rather snide style. I can totally understand that he must be very frustrated by now that the completely logical position he has championed for so long garners a surprising amount of rejection in certain circles. However, if he truly feels that "It would be so nice if those who oppose evolution would take a tiny bit of trouble to learn the merest rudiments of what it is that they are opposing." he might do well to take a different tone in his writings. If however, he is really just preaching to the converted, then this would likely explain the tone that he often seems to take.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- lazyant 17y agoI've read this calling Dawkins 'angry' a few times already and the stupid sensationalism bothers me: I've never seen him "angry", neither have I come across a written rant; he's always pretty calm.
- giardini 17y agoDerek Bickerton dissects Dawkins (and others) nicely: http://beyondscienceversusreligion.blogspot.com/2009/09/four-guys-against-god-5-richard-dawkins.html http://beyondscienceversusreligion.blogspot.com/2009/09/four... http://beyondscienceversusreligion.blogspot.com/2009/09/four-guys-against-god-6-dawkins-vgod-20.html http://beyondscienceversusreligion.blogspot.com/2009/09/four... Bickerton's blog "Beyond science versus religion": http://beyondscienceversusreligion.blogspot.com/2009/09/mission-statement.html http://beyondscienceversusreligion.blogspot.com/2009/09/miss... From Bickerton's mission statement: [He has an] "unwavering commitment to seek out bullshit and destroy it in all of its varying forms and disguises" [shades of the Augean stables!]. "This blog goes beyond the currently escalating struggle between science and religion, seeking new ways to reconcile them ... We'll go fearlessly where neither atheists nor believers have gone, submitting both sides to searching criticism they have not yet received. Earlier posts feature shortcomings of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse--Harris, Hitchens, Dawkins, Dennett--but then the religious get their turn."