3 ms·
Sigh. All true. We are mostly coders. We want to believe there is an authoritative language that can be parsed, lexically analyzed, tokenized, and yields consis
by noonespecial 17y ago
Sigh. All true. We are mostly coders. We want to believe there is an authoritative language that can be parsed, lexically analyzed, tokenized, and yields consistent meaning. It throws a peculiar kind of error in our brains when words or phrases change meanings on us. Its especially troubling when they come to mean the opposite of what was meant previously.
Language is uncomfortably emergent. I'll add "Could care less" to my big book of things to explain to foreigners about my native tongue. Idioms that sound like they could be real phrases are the hardest...
- codyrobbins 17y agoYes, that’s a very insightful remark! I was going to mention that human language and programming languages are fundamentally different things, but I already wrote too much. Interestingly, though, in the 1950s Chomsky’s first attempts at characterizing human language took just such a route, and involved simple transformational grammars and other concepts that did not work for human language, but turned out to be useful for the analysis of programming languages. As a result, we now learn about things like the Chomsky Hierarchy in undergraduate models of computation classes.
- jwhite 17y agoThanks for your long post, it was very informative and you've convinced me about "could care less". I think HN's apparently strange mix of anti-authoritarianism with prescriptive attitudes to language becomes easier to understand if you consider that the anti-authoritarianism is not an independent value, existing for its own sake. It goes hand in glove with a meritocratic value. HN contributors aim for and admire quality over authority, and I think that's a better explanation for the language pedantry we sometimes demonstrate. Of course I'm describing the ideal, which is not always achieved, and HN's idea of "quality" in the use of language is subjective.