3 ms·
I really enjoyed this. It lays out in some very accessible ways, the challenges of getting into space. The recoverability of the Falcon9 will cut its costs dram
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I really enjoyed this. It lays out in some very accessible ways, the challenges of getting into space. The recoverability of the Falcon9 will cut its costs dramatically as it reduces the cost of the launch by several tens of millions of $. I'll mention on-orbit refueling as well since you don't need recoverability per-se if you can refuel in orbit. Then your Mars lander / Crew Module can launch with enough fuel to get to Low Earth orbit, refuel, and then head out to Mars.
Air launched (Skylon, Pegasus, Et alia) are also interesting, laser boosting (using lasers to add energy during the initial launch) would also help. As Elon points out though, a multi-gigawatt laser for boost to orbit is impractical both from a construction standpoint and a diplomatic stability standpoint.
If the quantity of water on the moon is accurate, then it should be possible to create a 'refinery' on the Moon which could more easily get material into Earth orbit. We'll see though if we can get a group established there.
I had hoped to visit the Moon at some point (I was assured by NASA in my youth that would be able to :-)) but I don't expect that to come to pass unless something amazing changes.
- nickff 12y agoIf you do the math, air-launch does not save much in fuel costs, while it adds a great deal of complexity to the launch system, and you do not save much in terms of reduced energy requirements. Most of the rocket fuel and oxidizer are used to increase velocity; comparatively little is used to gain (the first 30k') altitude or lost to atmospheric drag. The main benefit to air-launch is reduced range safety costs, and ease of scheduling, as the launch vehicle can be taken out over an unoccupied stretch of ocean, and range rental/lease costs are basically eliminated.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAn interesting paper that is doing that math : http://mae.engr.ucdavis.edu/faculty/sarigul/aiaa2001-4619.pdf http://mae.engr.ucdavis.edu/faculty/sarigul/aiaa2001-4619.pd...