7 ms·
The author is afraid of his smart TV, but probably doesn't think twice about carrying around a smartphone. Smartphones have virtually all of the capabilities t
by pmoriarty 12y ago
The author is afraid of his smart TV, but probably doesn't think twice about carrying around a smartphone.
Smartphones have virtually all of the capabilities that make the author fear his smart TV, only the smartphone is, if anything, even more dangerous because it is more ubiquitous.
People carry their phones around everywhere, and the phones are usually constantly on and equally capable of monitoring your every word and action that you perform on them.
If you value privacy but own a smartphone, you've already lost.
- doctorshady 12y agoNot to detract from your point, but wouldn't that apply to cell phones in general?
- pmoriarty 12y agoYes, but to a lesser extent. The more powerful and well connected a device is, the less privacy its users tend to have. Unlike dumb phones, today's smartphones usually have built-in GPS capabilities, with relatively high-speed internet connections, powerful processors, a wealth of apps for their users to put their personal data in, and tight integration with social media. There was a time when spy agencies would have killed to plant devices with these sorts of surveillance capabilities on their marks. Today billions keep them on their persons at all times -- willingly, gladly even.
- zanny 12y agoIf you get hardware without proprietary radios (which, yeah, is impossible) and install only free software on it, you aren't lost. I use Paranoid Android, and I know my S4 can still use its radio to spy on me, but at least the OS itself isn't.
- pmoriarty 12y agoEnjoy your relative freedom while you can. In the so-called Internet of Things we're headed for, computers may be all-pervasive, wearable, embedded in everything, unobtrusive, practically indetectable and inescapable. They are likely to be always communicating with the other computers all around them, and privacy will be a dream of the past. Unfortunately, counter-surveillance technology does not appear to be keeping pace with surveillance technology, and since most people don't yet seem to care about being surveyed, there isn't much of a market for it. On the other side, most companies (and their oh-so-helpful tech enablers) love to spy on their users, and see nothing wrong with doing so (or at least don't let any moral qualms stand in the way of a profit). So there is a lot of incentive for spying and little incentive for not spying. Consciousness is slowly starting to emerge among the general population that this is happening, but there doesn't seem to be much of a backlash. Few are taking a stand.
- calgoo 12y ago"Unfortunately, counter-surveillance technology does not appear to be keeping pace with surveillance technology, and since most people don't yet seem to care about being surveyed, there isn't much of a market for it." EMP ?
- Nowyouknow 12y agoLess dramatic counter-surveillance technology.
- millstone 12y agoYour point about a smartphone's capabilities is well taken. But the TV straight-up says that your personal information will be captured and transmitted to a third party. I value my privacy, and trust (hope?) that my phone isn't transmitting that sort of stuff. If it did, I think it would be discovered and made public very quickly, and I would switch phones! But since the TV straight out says that it transmits my personal information, and I have no reason to doubt it, I'll be sure to not use that TV, or at least not connect it to the Internet. We can trust others to safeguard our privacy, as a sort of calculated risk. But this TV is just saying out loud that it won't do that, so I'll avoid that model.
- fulafel 12y agoAre you not counting Googhle or Apple as third parties?
- mmmm 12y agoDo they send sound from your phone to their servers non stop? If so, I'm switching from iPhone straight away.
- budu3 12y agoThe Moto X has a "Google Now" functionality where the continuously listens for you commands. Whatever is ships your sound off the Google server is another question.
- SlashmanX 12y agoThat's not how that works. There's something on the chip to just detect keywords, it's not a "always listening" thing
- noamyoungerm 12y agoSo does Google Now when you enable voice recognition inside other apps.
- gambiting 12y agoSmart phones are self-limiting though, because they mostly can't afford to be recording literally everything that is being said and then sending it off somewhere, because of battery concerns, and also the fact that majority of people are on limited data plans, so if the phone was constantly sending something it would have been noticed. Not so much with a TV - it's connected to mains power, and usually a broadband connection where sending some data is not going to be much of a problem.