6 ms·
When you mentioned Hindus and being stabbed in the back I remembered reading about Thugs http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thuggee http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/
by EGreg 12y ago
When you mentioned Hindus and being stabbed in the back I remembered reading about Thugs
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thuggee http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thuggee
Didn't they go around stabbing and strangling people?
- srean 12y agoUmmm... not quite sure what you mean here. They were, you know, thugs or highwaymen. Not what I would call historical representative of Hindu political ambitions. My point was that there have been many bloody wars fought by Hindu rulers motivated primarily / singularly by political ambition. Thus I find this much popularized universally pacifist portrayal of Hinduism a little dishonest. Short of political ambition, the subcontinent was rich in resources enough that there were no compelling reasons for large conquests and colonization of others. Had that not been so, no one knows how that would have played out.
- EGreg 12y agoI just mean you reminded me of it when you said "you know what I mean ..." and I remembered reading about that.
- carona 12y agoI have read your comments on this thread. Seems like you found a nice way to disguise your Anti-Hindu venting by packaging it as something barely relevant to this thread. Very nice progress made from the original topic: Tim Cook says I'm gay -> it's difficult to be Gay in India -> It's not just Indian Muslims who are Anti-Gay, and by the way Indian (or is it Hindu?) society has lot of other faults -> Hindu rulers had fought wars, and some other thing about Hinduism is dishonest
- defen 12y agoI figured it was a reference to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stab-in-the-back_myth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stab-in-the-back_myth
- judk 12y agoWow, that puts the anti Semitic and anti communist roots of Nazism way back in 1919. Such a long slow buildup, and nothing stopped it.
- srean 12y ago> Such a long slow buildup, and nothing stopped it. ... and that is exactly what scares the shit out of me. This is why I consider history a mandatory reading, more so a critical reading of history, with an eye for the tell tale signs. Playing with elements of hate and is playing with fire. You might recall that India and Pakistan were the same country once. Geopolitically they look different now, but I blame that on the butterfly effect of a few good decisions that leaders of India chose to abide by during its formative period (and stupid decisions on behalf of the Pakistani statesmen). What scares me is that this threat of a fascist future in India is not as ludicrous as I would like it to be. A few bad decisions, few people not choosing to stand up and India could be a non muslim version of the state of Pakistan now. Just for clarification, I bear no ill feeling towards Pakistani people, but they did really mess up their country and to me it seems for no good reason.
- dharmach 12y agoMuslims in Pakistan regularly kill minorities and is that due to butterfly effect? And still you are more worried about fascism in India!
- srean 12y ago> and is that due to butterfly effect ? Yes very much so. The initial condition and the differential equation were not that different for the two countries. The trajectory however turned out to be drastically different. The statesmen in charge during its formative period did not take steps which would have otherwise made such a scenario less likely. Small changes in courses of their actions early in its history, a decision here and there had major influence on how the country would shape up. They were not thinking ahead. It was a mistake to put religion in the center of politics. It was a mistake to cultivate this identity of the wronged population. Likewise for the now popular narrative of competing to be the better muslim, the roots of that narrative go farr back in time. Although Zia is the popular choice to ascribe the blame to, it had started way before. Bhutto (the father and the golden liberal boy) was for example very much in the business of deciding who is a true Muslim and who is not, deciding that Ahmadias are to be persecuted for not being pure enough Muslims, passing parliamentary laws to that effect. Check out why does Abdus Salam's grave in pakistan says "...became the first <defaced> Nobel laureate for his work in physics". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdus_Salam#mediaviewer/File:Grave_of_Abdus_Salam.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdus_Salam#mediaviewer/File:Gr... If Indian politicians play the same game, the consequences would be no different. We would get a non-muslim pakistan. > And still you are more worried about fascism in India! Yes and for a reason, because history does rhyme. > Muslims in Pakistan regularly kill minorities Perhaps you have a very cherry picked view of Indian history... since when has Hindu's in India not killed minorities. It seems to be a mandatory right of passage to take charge of national politics. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_riots_in_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_riots_in_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_India For those who are not very familiar with India, if you look closely you will see that some regions are regular and repeat offenders in post independence India whereas others are not affected.