3 ms·
I seem to remember reading that in an attempt to avoid "controversial" subjects, posts are penalized if they generate comments too quickly. Social issue are of
by slg 12y ago
I seem to remember reading that in an attempt to avoid "controversial" subjects, posts are penalized if they generate comments too quickly. Social issue are often hotly debated and occasionally some of the most actively commented on posts on the site until they drop off the front page. So while HN might not actively be penalizing these posts, they might be penalized in indirect but still very real ways.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI would hope that HN's "flamewar" detector is somewhat more sophisticated than just "generate comments too quickly".
- waterlesscloud 12y agoThere's an aspect of it that's a ratio of comments to upvotes, which seems to work pretty well from what I've observed.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoNow that makes more sense. A story that generates a large number of comments and a large number of upvotes very quickly seems likely to be a good story. A story that generates many quick comments without upvotes seems likely to have produced comments negative about the article; if you posting a comment but you don't want to upvote the article, that does seem like a good sign of controversy and possible flames.
- slg 12y agoBut it doesn't just penalize flamewars, it penalizes all conversations. For example, I have now posted two comments in this discussion and only upvoted the article once. Does that mean this is a worse article than one that I only upvoted and never commented on or a better article than one I upvoted and commented on three times?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoKeep in mind that HN also has a "deep thread" mechanism, which hides the reply button for a while on sufficiently deep comment threads to discourage rapid-fire posting without thought. (Slashdot used to have the same thing; if you posted comments too rapidly, you'd get a "whoa, slow down there".) I'd also hope that more weight goes to "more commenters than upvotes" rather than "more comments than upvotes", though as vague heuristics neither seems too far off.
- krapp 12y agoI think it's mistaken to assume that not upvoting and downvoting are each implicitly negative, though. There is a neutral dimension to subthreads as well - conversations which are neither praiseworthy nor trolling.
- krapp 12y agoI believe a thread with more comments than votes is penalized as well, suggesting that commenting on a thread without upvoting it first is implicitly flagging it. And of course there may be other arcane metrics involving thread depth, average comment rate, comment size, thread shape, etc. Who knows?
- Chinjut 12y agoWhoa, really? ...I've been flagging a lot of articles.
- AndrewDucker 12y agoOnly a factor if it's got more comments than upvotes.