4 ms·
I'm wondering that as well. In particular, it seems like content that's more likely to be shared via various social networks would be more likely to set off th
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
I'm wondering that as well. In particular, it seems like content that's more likely to be shared via various social networks would be more likely to set off the ring-voting detector.
- minimaxir 12y agoYou're confusing correlation with causation. Sure, many article at the top of HN after often posted elsewhere (e.g. today) because they are incredibly newsworthy. However, a HN post that people share on social media network for the purpose of upvotes is a different story.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI'm not assuming either correlation or causation; I'm suggesting a hypothesis that seems worth testing and evaluating. There's a difference in motivation between "check this interesting article out" and "please upvote me", but the ring-voting detector can't necessarily tell the difference.
- minimaxir 12y ago> There's a difference in motivation between "check this interesting article out" and "please upvote me", but the ring-voting detector can't necessarily tell the difference.' In the former case, why would they be linking to HN in the first place, instead of the article itself? HN has a basic voting ring heuristic to ignore votes from direct links to HN submissions from a non-HN referrer for this reason.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI can't speak for other people, but personally, when I find a good article, I link to the source I found it through, rather than bypassing the source and linking directly to the article. (I don't do that when submitting stories to HN since HN considers that "blogspam", but personally I like finding new sources of good content, as well as sources of good discussion, rather than just the content itself. And in any case that's a heuristic for what to submit to HN rather than what to link to from elsewhere.) At a minimum, I would tend to put something like this: interesting article (link to article) via HN (link to HN). Though I'm certainly less likely to do that now that I know that HN does not like such links. I don't think it's appropriate to post something like that about one's own story, but for a story you found interesting and want to share, I think it makes sense.