3 ms·
While I realize you can't go into too much detail about ring-voting detection to prevent people from finding ways around it, can you elaborate a bit on what rin
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
While I realize you can't go into too much detail about ring-voting detection to prevent people from finding ways around it, can you elaborate a bit on what ring-voting means to HN, beyond the obvious?
The obvious definition would be a clique of accounts that all upvote each other's stories, but that seems rather unlikely in this case; is there a secondary criteria? Are you looking to prohibit what Wikipedia calls "meatpuppetry"? Are you also looking to prevent upvotes from people who reach an HN discussion via Twitter or other sites?
- dang 12y agoI'm happy to elaborate on nearly any aspect of Hacker News, but this is one area (maybe the only area?) where I resist the impulse to explain. We're in something of an arms race against a lot of people who try to get their content on the front page through non-organic means. Accidentally helping them do so would be a genuine shot in the foot. But let's say what good voting means to HN. It means voting for something that you personally find intellectually interesting, regardless of who posted it and regardless of what you or your friends are hoping to promote.