4 ms·
I suppose the idea is that "the CO2 has to be bought and used anyway" and so this atmosphere-extracted CO2 would displace it, thereby substituting for CO2 that
by SilasX 12y ago
I suppose the idea is that "the CO2 has to be bought and used anyway" and so this atmosphere-extracted CO2 would displace it, thereby substituting for CO2 that would otherwise be a net addition.
That is, instead of
[other source] -> [atmosphere]
it would be
[atmosphere] -> [atmosphere]
OTOH, there could be a sort of "reverse Jevons effect" here, where this simply bids down the price of CO2 and leads people to simply put it to more uses, so this new source is simply in addition to all those other traditional CO2 sources.
- aetherson 12y agoBut the premise of this technology is not simply that it mitigates carbon gain in the atmosphere, but that it can actually sink away some of the carbon produced by the (vastly more significant than direct industrial uses of CO2) fossil fuel industry. If all it can do is mitigate the amount of carbon released into the atmosphere by greenhouses and beverages, then that seems so unimportant that it can't possibly be worth bothering with.