5 ms·
Though I hate social engineering taxes, the easy way to fix the regressive nature of the fat tax would be to cut a cheque to every person legally living in the
by 3pt14159 17y ago
Though I hate social engineering taxes, the easy way to fix the regressive nature of the fat tax would be to cut a cheque to every person legally living in the country. While the poor now have to pay, say, $1000 more per year they are also cut a cheque worth $1100, giving them real choice between healthy and nonheathly.
- gaius 17y agoNah, that's not how it works. I rarely go to supermarkets any more but when I do I always see the same thing: fat mothers, fat kids, trolley full of processed food and then to the cigarette kiosk to load up on fags, gossip and TV magazines, and lottery tickets. You can feed a family of four healthy food bought from the market for a day for the cost of 20 smokes - Indian and Italian food in particular is incredibly cheap to make from scratch. The problem is not one of affordability. Anyone who says it is has a political agenda.
- skolor 17y agoKind of. Having lived for the past two years now on the low end of the income spectrum, eating well is definitely more expensive than eating for the least possible. White bread is cheaper than Whole Wheat. Low fat meats are always more expensive than the fattier meats. Mind you, either way it is cheaper or it breaks even at worst when compared to buying pre-processed foods, but the point is: you can save some money by eating a little worse.
- gaius 17y agoIt depends on how much prep you're prepared to do. You can make a hearty lentil curry very cheaply, for example, if you buy the basic ingredients in bulk. 'Course this presupposes that you know how to cook, but that knowledge is very nearly free, the only investment is in time.
- randallsquared 17y agoBut the time investment is considerable. One reason I don't cook more (and I do cook 3-8 times a week) is that to make anything except a few very simple dishes, there's so much coordination that it's barely worth it. Most recipes call for 5-15 different ingredients, and the chances are very good that you'll be out of at least one, and if you try to stock up so that it's less likely, stuff goes bad before you can get to it. The only solution I know is to go to the store to buy ingredients every day or two, which adds an average of half an hour prep time to each meal (assuming you go every two or three meals, optimistically). Also, the first few times I make something, it'll often not be very good, meaning that I have to be prepared to eat a few meals I don't even like, and which take extra time, just to learn a new dish. If I'm in an experimental mood, that's fine, but most of the time I just want to put in minimal effort and have a nice meal to eat while watching Sons of Anarchy or whatever. I guess the summary is: lots of time, and getting the knowledge of how to make something costs several unenjoyable meals and extra cooking time on top of that.
- theBobMcCormick 17y agoWasn't it pointed out in a previous article linked here on HN that the poor tend to have less free time?
- hughprime 17y agoSome poor people have too little free time (the ones working two minimum-wage jobs) while others have too much (the unemployed). It would be interesting to compare the obesity rates of the two groups. I doubt you'd find that the unemployed were thinner.
- catzaa 17y ago> White bread is cheaper than Whole Wheat. But brown bread is cheaper (and healthier) than white bread.
- roc 17y agoI personally agree with your objective assertion (it's not a question of affordability of healthier food). But it's awfully dirty pool to build straw men and convenient demons and then pass judgment on anyone advancing a contrary position with a judgment about their motivations.
- TrevorJ 17y agoIncidentally, the social engineering aspects of tax law are the reason we will never see a flat tax. Tax is as much about behavior modification as it is about revenue.
- hughprime 17y agoNot really. The main reason we'll never see a flat tax is because as soon as a flat tax is enacted, a politician can easily gain votes by promising to lower taxes for 99% of the population by raising them on the top 1%.
- TrevorJ 17y agoThat's no different than a politician saying they will lower taxes if they are elected right now. Granted, the simplicity of implementation would be easier if it where a flat tax, but the difficulty it always in getting the legislation passed, just as it is today.
- hughprime 17y agoI'm just saying that taxes tend to head towards a level somewhere between the economic optimum (as flat as possible) and the political optimum (all taxes paid by a tiny minority).
- TrevorJ 17y agoAh, I see, that is an interesting observation. I wonder if you could map this using some of Nashs' work.