4 ms·
The sticking point seems to be the energy required to process the CO2. How to get that energy in a way that doesn't produce more CO2 than is captured seems like
by cratermoon 12y ago
The sticking point seems to be the energy required to process the CO2. How to get that energy in a way that doesn't produce more CO2 than is captured seems like a hard problem, approaching a violation of the laws of thermodynamics.
Perhaps the reason he's gotten little interest so far is that he hasn't shown his process to be CO2-negative, and the experts are skeptical of what might amount to a very complicated version of yet another perpetual motion machine.
- humanrebar 12y agoI've wondered why we can't capture carbon by using plant matter (or by-products) to meet existing needs for durable goods like buildings and manufactured good that end up in landfills. Capturing CO2 this way doesn't require storage tanks or energy capture. Has there been any research along these lines?
- chc 12y agoWhat does this mean? People living in live trees?
- nine_k 12y agoDead trees (cellulose) keep the carbon pretty fine. Build more wooded houses, etc. It's important to not let them rot, though, because this releases CO₂ back to the atmosphere.
- graycat 12y agoI thought that when wood and other plants rotted, the main result was a lot of soil which I thought was heavily carbon, from the plants, from CO2, from the atmosphere. Maybe I'm wrong about this? Or, growing up, Dad put a lot of ammonium nitrate NH4NO3 fertilizer on the lawn. Then the lawn grew fast enough that I got the job to mow the grass twice a week instead of once each other week. After growing up in that house with that lawn, all the grass clippings raised the level of the top soil by about 1.5" -- this was easy to see next to the concrete driveway and walk ways which I observed close at hand as I ran the electric edger, with its 35,000 RPM motor, between the concrete and the lawn. So, CO2 from the atmosphere turned into grass turned into grass clippings turned into top soil which no doubt had a lot of carbon, originally from the CO2 in the atmosphere. While this is many years later and I moved away long ago, I have to believe that that top soil is still there and very much is not going anywhere, certainly not as CO2 back into the atmosphere. Net, a lawn commonly does sequester carbon from CO2 in the atmosphere. Here I'm just giving this point as a biological fact and without any judgment about this situation being good, bad, or otherwise for anything in particular.
- nine_k 12y ago"Rotting" usually means being slowly consumed by fungi and bacteria, which ultimately break a good part of the cellulose down to very simple compounds like CO₂ and water.
- chc 12y agoI don't think nuclear, solar, wind or hydro plants produce much CO2.
- fiatmoney 12y agoThe manufacturing, maintenance, & mining processes backing them do, albeit less than, e.g., a coal-fired power plant.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThe whole premise of carbon capture is that we're still burning fossil fuels. If the world literally eliminated 100% of carbon emissions then biological carbon sinks (plants) would eventually restore the natural equilibrium, the problem is we're burning more carbon than they can keep up with. Using nuclear power to sequester carbon is useless if someone else is still using carbon to power their air conditioner or whatever, you would do better to just use the nuclear power to run the air conditioner.
- bdamm 12y agoThere are lots of good reasons to burn carbon to produce energy. What we need is a carbon tax that goes to operations such as these, bound to the waste energy from nuclear or solar plants, for example. That way the carbon emissions can be offset by the carbon intake. Maybe we could burn all the carbon we wanted, at a rate even far exceeding the rate we make carbon emissions today, if those emissions were balanced with large-scale carbon removal. If that carbon removal produced fuel, that would be fine - the balance would be a lot closer to zero, and more importantly, we could have a control on the acceptable carbon in the atmosphere.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThere is no "burn all the carbon we wanted" regardless of climate change because we're eventually going to run out of cheap oil. The cost of recovering it will eventually exceed the cost of renewable energy. The problem is that waiting until that point to stop burning oil and coal would do catastrophic damage to the planet. The thing that makes much better sense is to have a carbon tax and use the money to subsidize non-fossil energy on a per KWh basis, and set the amount such that it makes non-fossil energy cheaper. Do that and the market would sort it out in short order.