What do you think a slave should do if it is told to replace its state with empty state? How about half-empty state? There's really no answer that's satisfyin

What do you think a slave should do if it is told to replace its state with empty state? How about half-empty state? There's really no answer that's satisfying for every possible use case (certainly I don't want my slaves to refuse if I tell them to clear the database completely on purpose). And indeed you haven't given any examples of databases that try to do 'better'. I think that's because there aren't any.