3 ms·
> liberal arts ... teaches you to argue any point of view, right or wrong, with equal facility Is this really a good thing? There are certainly plenty of thing
by mindslight 12y ago
> liberal arts ... teaches you to argue any point of view, right or wrong, with equal facility
Is this really a good thing? There are certainly plenty of things in this world that are relative, unanswerable, or heuristics based on differing utility functions. But arguments about those things should still be logically right, based on differing assumptions that are made explicit.
- emotionalcode 12y agoI did not consider it a good thing, when I had convinced myself and all my opinions to lay at a middle/neutral point where I couldn't select a single one. It made me feel as though I had no sense of self. I studied a bit of Zen with some folks, where I started simplifying every point of view to 'thinking about thinking', or a deconstructionist approach to every conceptual construction. This allowed me to assign a more weighted value to every opinion I could have, so I felt as though I was being somewhat more careful. With this mindset, I still feel as though I am tricking myself, but, I add concepts/values/ideas/understandings/acceptance of understandings much more slowly and less definitively. Even then, there's the foggy feeling that remains, every thought exists in some context with some assumptions. You can continue to question what assumptions exist that you aren't aware of, and redefine your opinions through that vocabulary instead, and perhaps convince yourself into a point of view you would never consciously switch to given knowledge of the prior, through the trickery of time and language. Trying to maintain a coherent view of the world assuming the possibility of relativism across all domains is insanity. Trying to function with that mass of unanswerables leading to possibly infinitely descending chains of undefined, fuzzy variables is like hitting a wall of meaningless symbols. It makes doing things in reality trivial. The task of coming to know what you explicitly, continuously define as unknowable is impossible. In theory, logic is beautiful. But there's stuff that makes logic seem incomplete, when it comes to application. At the trail end of the thought, it still feels like thinking about everything all at once, while knowing nothing.
- ForHackernews 12y agoYou already agree with the person you're responding to and trying to convince.
- mindslight 12y agoYeah, I realized that. But his point is a bit narrow and strawmanish, so I thought it should be expanded. The entire world isn't engineering, and there are plenty of things that we have to agree to disagree on (we can come up with objective solutions that minimize the disagreement, but that only goes so far). Since softer subjects will always lack clear objective answers, we could hope for a change in liberal arts teaching that required creating independent rational arguments rather than getting by by restating the specific one the professor happens to believe in.
- WalterBright 12y agoLet me put it another way. A science/engineering program teaches you the scientific method, which is the best technique ever discovered for separating truth from crap. That's a critical thinking skill that actually works. As opposed to, say, arguing about who is a better President - Obama or Bush? Liberal arts majors can argue that all day, and never be able to demonstrate a thing to be true.
- yaketysax 12y agoThere is a lot more to political philosophy than "Is president X better than president Y?". Moreover, who's claiming that something has to be demonstrated as true? You find no value whatsoever in discussing and considering different axioms?
- WalterBright 12y agoDiscussing them is fine. How does one determine which axiom is correct? Especially given that a skilled debater can persuasively argue either side? Note that there have been many scientific theories that were debated persuasively, reasonably, and logically, until someone applied the scientific method and proved one side correct and the other false.
- mindslight 12y agoCompletely agreed, yet there are topics that reside between those two extremes of objective truth and celebrity ephemera. Unable to be decided through science, yet still "up for decision" anyway (lovely passive voice!). This is what liberal arts is supposed to prepare one to address. But rather than correct reasoning being differentiated from crap reasoning, even among educated people we get passionate emotional appeals that ultimately devolve into tribal us-vs-them behavior.
- johnchristopher 12y agoCould you please offer evidence to support your statement that liberal arts major are never able to demonstrate a thing to be true and also, as an example, apply the scientific method to the question `who is a better President - Obama or Bush?`