8 ms·
What I learned from reading 8,000 recruiting messages
- linker3000 12y agoI learned that the author hasn't checked out their web site from a phone. A big subscription window pops up, overhangs the right half of the screen and can't be closed because you can't reach the button. Couldn't read article.
- windsurfer 12y agoWorks fine here: http://i.imgur.com/fG4I3Q3.png http://i.imgur.com/fG4I3Q3.png
- cordite 12y agoI wish that subscription window happened near the end, not at the beginning when I'm reading the first paragraph--that's just distracting.
- leeny 12y agofixed!
- leeny 12y agoauthor here. thanks; fixing this right now.
- thomasfromcdnjs 12y agoHighly recommend reading all of her post, very genuine and insightful view of recruiting.
- minimaxir 12y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8103540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8103540 As I mentioned in those comments, the statistical analysis is a bit arbitrary and not very scientific.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoEven if the statistical analysis was sound the conclusions don't follow. The "effect" of personalized responses may be due to multi-colinearity: personal letters may be written only in cases when there is a genuine personal connection, so adding personalization may have no effect in other circumstances. There are other issues as well, but that's the most obvious. The whole thing is a cautionary tale of not doing data analysis when you don't have appropriate training and experience.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mavelikara 12y agoFrom a quick scan I could not find the author discussing it, but I found it amusing that the response rates did not increase as the bid-to-ask ratio increased past 1.1. I think this is because a job which advertises pay significantly more than what the engineer's preferred salary is signals that the job could be out of their league.
- zippergz 12y agoOr that there's some other reason it's undesirable and they have to pay people a lot to do it...
- mavelikara 12y agoGood point.
- ilghiro 12y agoI think you've missed something here, the response rate does increase, it's the % of offers that fall into that category that is represented by the bell curve.
- codegeek 12y agoNo brainer about a few things. No matter what anyone says, unless a recruiter gives you the following information, I am not interested: - Salary Range. yes, a range. don't give me crap like "market rate" and "depends on experience". That's the same as saying "we won't tell you". It is understood that not everyone can negotiate the same amount of money but the range is crucial to know. For example, if I want to get paid 150K base salary and the range says 100-120K, I am not going to be bothered any further. - Name of the client/company: Please don't play games with this one. Either you tell me the name or I am out. I don't wanna hear "Fortune 500 client with great benefits". really ? - What are they looking for? Ok this one is subjective and sometimes difficult for a recruiter to explain. Totally understood. But please work with the hiring manager on understanding their requirement more. I blame hiring managers more on this one. I have got calls saying "we need an excellent C++ developer but donno any further details". Umm no. - Location: Where will I need to be ? If you don't know, then I am not going to guess. I cannot move to Austin from New York (well I can't) Only when I know these things at a minimum from a recruiter, they will get my attention.
- githulhu 12y agoIf they told you the company, what would stop you from just bypassing the recruiter and going straight to the company?
- kstenerud 12y agoWhat purpose would that serve? Why go to the trouble of cold-calling a company when I already have an inside track via this recruiter?
- potatolicious 12y agoCompensation - ultimately the company has a budget for hiring for a role, which would include any fees required to bring you on board. In many (not all) cases the recruiter's fee subtracts from your own salary negotiations. Also, a lot of recruiters are not retained but work on contingency, so they're at best arms-length from the companies they "work" for - it's questionable how "inside" they are. Going with them may not confer as much of an advantage to getting the job as one might think. In any case, I feel like tech recruiting is a poor solution that encompasses two problems: job discovery, and candidate discovery. Recruiting is effective at the latter, but oftentimes is used to fulfill the former.
- elmuchoprez 12y agoI found the use of slightly different shades of the same color to differentiate data bars to be incredibly frustrating, which made me assume this was written by a marketer and not someone with a technical background. Fair or not, that instantly made the message less interesting to me. Anyways, just an interesting take on another type of factor that can impact recruiting messaging.
- furyofantares 12y agoI suppose you'd need a much bigger sample size but I'd be very interested in a continued analysis on how many of those that responded went on to get offers and how many accepted. The comment about salary ranges got me thinking about this, giving me a range probably increases my response rate but then if I am later offered the low end of the range am I less likely to accept than it I hadn't been given the range? Maybe, so it isn't at all clear to me that maximizing response rate maximizes hiring rate.
- cpfohl 12y agoGateway errors all over for me...
- VLM 12y agoA fun secondary analysis would be cost estimate. So a truly personal message might cost an hour of labor, but a form letter costs only a few seconds to make sure you're sending the correct letter. On the scale of $ expended per decent candidate, form letters would appear to be much better than personal messages, even if they are less effective. WRT "Instead I wrote a little script that hashed messages with an edit distance" an alternative, possibly faster strategy, might be vocabulary. Look at the form letters full of meaningless idioms and cliches, total corporate-speak, all "believe" and "passionate" (that word is only used in cheap pr0n and corporate speak) and "casual" (See commentary on "passionate") and "challenge" "fit" "strong" (what is this ESPN Sportscenter or a recruitment email?) and "Agile" (which has been poisoned in the market to mean absolutely nothing now) How the corporate-speak form letters avoided classics like the phrase "work life balance" is a mystery. Words like "opportunity" and "experience" are kind of on the bubble and generally indicate corporate-speak. Relative lack of corporate-speak vocabulary in the personalized written by and for humans messages is also apparent. (edited to add, an interesting difficult startup idea would be addons for word processors or web browsers which highlight corporate-speak words and phrases to dramatically improve writing styles. Any time "key takeaways" or "metric" appears in the text box its underlined in yellow or something.)
- Lambent_Cactus 12y ago"Despite the title of this post, reading almost 8,000 messages and scoring them for how personal they were was clearly intractable." Big data!
- ColinWright 12y agoNote that all the graphs in this post are interactive, so you can hover and do other fun things. 502 Bad Gateway nginx/1.4.6 (Ubuntu)
- minimaxir 12y agoThe graphs are using plot.ly, which are externally hosted. I don't understand the appeal of interactive charts for simple, static data.
- sriram_sun 12y agoI'd like to pick on the point that Founders and Engineers are as guilty as Recruiters in terms of sending boiler plate messages.Recruiter: 53%, Founder: 49%, Engineer: 47%. A recruiter's _only_ job is to recruit talented people. A founder/engineer has other things to do. Yes they should be spending a significant portion of their time recruiting. How realistic is that expectation though? Also, how do the %s above add to 100 unless there is a significant overlap between Engineers and Founders?
- notastartup 12y agoBeing sent on a goose chase. Been to interviews where the recruiter sent me for a role that didn't exist. Had recruiters call from blocked numbers. When a recruiter from a recruitment company contacts me on linkedin, I immediately flag and block them.
- pyrrhotech 12y agoSalary range is the most crucial point. I would not take a sub $120k job under any circumstances, so please don't waste my time. Sub $140k would have to be a very good opportunity at a rocket ship with boatloads of equity. If you want responses, be honest and up front on what you are willing to pay, then we can start to filter through the other information.
- leeny 12y agoAuthor of the original post here. Happy to answer any questions!
- sriram_sun 12y agoNice articles in general! The MS vs BS was spot on. So are the observations on GitHub projects in "Lessons from a year's worth of hiring data"
- dang 12y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?q=What+I+learned+from+reading+8%2C000+recruiting+messages#!/story/forever/0/What%20I%20learned%20from%20reading%208%2C000%20recruiting%20messages https://hn.algolia.com/?q=What+I+learned+from+reading+8%2C00...