4 ms·
For those that do not understand why deflation is considered dangerous, let me describe it this way: It is effectively like cash earning tax-free interest. And
by jandrewrogers 12y ago
For those that do not understand why deflation is considered dangerous, let me describe it this way:
It is effectively like cash earning tax-free interest. And since it is cash, that "investment" is virtually risk-free because you'll always have the cash.
As a consequence, simply holding cash starts competing with the expected return of investing the cash in other ways, like real estate, government bonds, the stock market, or a startup. Relative to some traditional investments, you might maximize your effective risk-adjusted returns by doing nothing at all!
This sounds great (at least for people with cash) until you realize that this "investment" is one of the least productive investments possible. No infrastructure is built, no technologies invented, no products are created for customers. While people with cash might be nominally wealthier, there is greatly reduced investment of cash in things that improve the productivity and wealth of the entire economy.
Furthermore, real investment is how many jobs are created. Several million jobs in the United States are paid for with funds from speculative investments. If it no longer pays to make speculative investments on new technologies, new startups, or otherwise changing the world, what do you think happens to those jobs that are tacitly funded by that investment?
Mild inflation, for better or worse, incentivizes anyone with a bit of money to use that money to fund companies, infrastructure, technology, and jobs that may ultimately return higher value than the loss to inflation. Yes, if you sit on your cash in an inflationary economy, you slowly lose wealth. It incentivizes people to attempt to apply their assets toward productive ends.
Lastly, there is the question of what about people with little or no cash in an inflationary environment? On the surface, it looks like they get screwed. In practice, the productivity and technology advances created by the investment by people with money are often effectively neutral or deflationary. Not only are they more productive at their jobs, assuming they have one, but the costs of many goods decline thanks to the investment. This doesn't apply to all goods but it applies to many that almost everyone consumes. That said, if an economy inflates too fast it can quickly outstrip the earning potential of the people that operate in it. The flow of money through an economy has a significant viscosity and in extreme cases that causes much suffering.
In summary, the reason mildly inflationary economies are commonly preferred by most governments is that, on the balance, it optimizes incentives to maximize real investment which not only grows the economy in real terms but has quasi-deflationary effects for consumers as well. There are always tradeoffs but this is widely believed to have the "least bad" set of tradeoffs for a currency inflation/deflation policy.
- drcode 12y agoYour argument may have merit, but it oversimplifies an important point (in my opinion) If money is "hidden under blankets" it is taken out of circulation. The value per unit currency still in circulation increases (due to lack of supply) and this will boost the purchasing power of the money remaining in circulation. For this reason the idea that "deflation causes a liquidity crisis" is a bit misleading- It causes a liquidity crises measured in "face value" but not in "purchasing power" of the currency. (Though some of your prognoses are probably still true but occur because of other, somewhat different mechanisms)
- chimeracoder 12y ago> Mild inflation, for better or worse, incentivizes anyone with a bit of money to use that money to fund companies, infrastructure, technology, and jobs that may ultimately return higher value than the loss to inflation. Yes, if you sit on your cash in an inflationary economy, you slowly lose wealth. It incentivizes people to attempt to apply their assets toward productive ends. One other point: inflation is actually beneficial to people who are in debt[0], as it reduces the real value of their debt. (In other words, the dollar that they use to pay off the debt a year from now is worth less than the dollar today, so inflation literally allows them to use less money[1] to pay off their debt). Conversely, deflation is terrible for people who are in debt, as it effectively increases the amount of money they have to spend to pay off the debt (this is on top of the compounding interest; it is looking at the real value of the same nominal dollar amount). So, one of the biggest dangers of deflation is that it harms people with negative net worth (people deeply in debt)[2]. [0] Assuming fixed interest rates [1] In real terms, not nominal terms [2] The people who 'win' in this particular context are the people who own that debt (ie, the bankers). But as jandrewrodgers pointed out, there are a number of other ways that deflation harms them as well, so deflation is really a lose-lose situation.
- w4 12y agoThis, aside from the wage concerns mentioned elsewhere in the comments, is the huge problem with deflation. Anyone with debt (got a mortgage or student loans? This is you we're talking about then) gets a huge kick in the balls, which is compounded by wage cuts or, at best, stagnant wages.