3 ms·
It hurts everyone as the economy shrinks and there's less cash to go around. That's who.
by Nursie 12y ago
It hurts everyone as the economy shrinks and there's less cash to go around.
That's who.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- msandford 12y ago> It hurts everyone as the economy shrinks and there's less cash to go around. Only until prices fall enough that people start spending again and hiring picks up again. The idea of an evenly rotating economy where everything is great all the time has been thoroughly disproven over 100 years ago. To try and manage the economy to be so is a fool's errand. Debt has grown ever-so-slightly faster than income for the last 40-50 years and that means future purchases have been pulled to the present for the last 40-50 years. If history is a guide (and I believe that it is) one of two things will happen: 1. People will start to pay down their debt and this will unfortunately result in hardship as debt-fueled growth stops 2. The banks will print more money and the party never stops until the party blows up in an enormous currency crisis I can't tell you which will happen, but every time we print more money we grow the systemic risk of total blowup. People who argue that we should be doing more to prevent climate change while simultaneously cheering money-printing need to take a good look at their belief systems.
- ap22213 12y agoSo, you're saying that you want another Great Depression? That's generally not considered as a positive period of time.
- Nursie 12y ago>>Only until prices fall enough that people start spending again and hiring picks up again. But why would I bother investing capital to hire people to make stuff if I've got guaranteed returns just by sitting on cash?
- msandford 12y agoDeflation is only a scary thing because people have adapted to inflation, and that has shaped the last 100 years or so of financial history in this country. It used to be that prices went up, then down, then back up again, then back down again, etc on a time-scale of a couple of years. Maybe spanning a range of 4x or so. Because everyone knew that's how things went, they arranged their affairs to cope and things weren't amazing, but a year or two of deflation didn't destroy the world. What we have now are huge asset bubbles that are popping and people at the Fed are trying to reflate and/or at least slow the collapse down. The problem isn't that deflation might happen; it's that there were years and years of asset prices going to more and more unreasonable levels that no sane person would pay. How do you clean the slate and get asset prices back to levels that might make sense from a fundamentals perspective instead of a risk-on, risk-off perspective? The only thing I can think of is to let them fall to levels where people would be willing to buy them again. It's either that or a 20 year inflationary slog to slowly reprice them in real terms. In other words, at 4% inflation over 20 years if a price doesn't change in nominal terms it'll lose 55% of its value in real terms. That roughly approximates it dropping in value 50% in say 6 months nominally, because in 6 months nominal terms are unlikely to diverge from real terms by more than a few percent. Which would you rather have? 20 year of Japan or the Great Depression, or a fairly swift realignment of the economy to the new realities? Either way the assets have to get repriced once everyone realized that they were priced horribly, horribly incorrectly.
- Houshalter 12y agoThe amount of wealth is constant. Just because there is more cash in the economy, doesn't mean anything if it's worth less. You might see some benefit in the short term but only at the expense of the long term. People, and the economy as a whole, should save/invest for the future as much as possible, rather than only caring about the short term.
- MCRed 12y agoDeflation means you can buy the same amount of goods (sustaining the same sized economy) with less money. That less money means you have more surplus money to spend on luxuries. More people will have more disposable income, which likely would mean they buy more goods, and could sustain a larger economy... leading to economic growth. Plus-- the goods you're buying are made by companies who are buying materials at a lower cost, and thus if they lower prices slower than the materials prices are going down due to inflation they have more margin. Businesses as well will have more flexibility, the ones that are borderline now will last longer, might turn things around, etc.
- Nursie 12y agoYou're also getting paid less over time. Meanwhile my savings are slowly growing in economic power, even though all I've done is stuff them in an old mattress. New entrants to the labour market can never aspire to have the kind of cash their older peers have put away because work yesterday is valued more than work today. Not a world I want to live in.