4 ms·
WhatsApp Lost $138M Last Year
- joelrunyon 12y agoSo that's less than 1% of their worth ($19B sale). Does that seem like such a huge number now?
- davis_m 12y ago"worth"
- jordanthoms 12y agoI think in 5 years 19B will look cheap to own messaging in a substantial portion of the world.
- jliptzin 12y agoYou mean 10%
- selectodude 12y ago138 million is 10 percent of 1.3 billion.
- headsupftw 12y agoYes, it does because it's a number of net loss. Nobody buys a business to lose money.
- joelrunyon 12y agoIf they're investing in research & development - they're likely not looking at is as a loss - rather a business expense.
- jasonwilk 12y ago$206.5 million of that loss was for share-based compensation expenses and issuance of common stock below fair value -TC This is a poor headline.
- sah88 12y agoSorry I see the 98.5 for the year end 2013 but I don't see how your getting to 206.5 from there? Their total costs are only 148m on the statement of operations. Also presumably some of that stock based compensation is in lieu of paying cash. I'm not sure its fair to discount it entirely. edit: I sleuthed out what TC means. Tech Crunch are referencing first half of 2014 this article is year end 2013.
- himeag 12y agoDid anyone else stop using WhatsApp after acquisition due to Facebook's privacy policies?
- thrownaway2424 12y agoDid they actually change the terms?
- yuhong 12y agoAnd would they in this day and age?
- eugeneionesco 12y agoI did and moved to Telegram.
- eitally 12y agoI tried, and I only use it for 1 specific group conversation, but it's a group with about 40 people in it and only a small minority were willing to switch [to Telegram], due to their own network effects. :(
- onedev 12y agoI really wish more of my friends were willing to use Telegram. It's really one of the best messaging apps that I've used.
- drham 12y ago"Research and development at the start-up, which employed just 55 people at the time it was sold, totaled $77 million" I'm super-confused by this, can anyone explain what sorts of expenses would be this high and labeled as R&D costs for a company like WhatsApp?
- threeseed 12y agoFrom what we've seen Facebook acquisitions move over to the Facebook infrastructure. That could mean bringing in expensive consultants to assist.
- sah88 12y agoProbably taxes. There are non-trivial tax credits for R&D spending. My guess is they shoehorned as much of their costs into R&D as they could. You can see they got 1.2 million in R&D credits in 2013 in the referenced document.
- necubi 12y agoRight. It's SOP for tech companies to list basically all of engineering as R&D for tax purposes.
- beartime 12y agowhatsapp is grown almost 2x since fb's acquisition. source: i know
- mariusz79 12y agoIt's hard to believe that app that is free for a year and than 99 cents per year could be losing money. /sarc
- Pxtl 12y agoIt's not exactly shunting vast amounts of data, I'd think a buck per year per user would be pretty good for text messaging.
- kenrikm 12y agoGiven that it's unlikely users will jump ship if they are happy with it over $1/year and the fact that they have 400 million users I think there's a pretty good chance that revenue number will come up.
- thaumasiotes 12y ago...but there are so many options to send text messages for free. Why pay the $1 / year?
- feld 12y agoPrivacy and no ads. The "free" alternatives are not "free".
- Nursie 12y agoHave you tried textsecure?
- forgotpasswd3x 12y agoTelegram is "free". I'm not sure why "free" needs to be in quotes. I don't know how I feel about Privacy being touted as a benefit of using anything owned by Facebook.
- melvinmt 12y agoI think FB cares more about ruling the world than WhatsApp's P&L statement. From "Mobile is Eating The World" [1]: Global SMS: 7.5tr messages a year WhatsApp: 7.2tr messages a year (with just 30 engineers) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8524256 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8524256
- wavefunction 12y agoOf course we should note that WhatsApp (and Facebook!) is piggy-backing on the work of the many thousands of telecom engineers who have over the years built and maintained the infrastructure that both Facebook and WhatsApp require to survive.
- ddrmaxgt37 12y agoAnd we are all piggy-backing on whoever invented the wheel.
- outside1234 12y agoYou mean the one we pay for each month in our mobile bill?
- downandout 12y agoI think the Whatsapp price was a huge blunder by Zuck. Whatsapp has lots of users - most of whom are in countries viewed as almost worthless by advertisers. Their US footprint is insignificant, and shows no signs of growing here or in many other valuable countries. Their current revenue - $10.2M/year with 400M users - shows their users' propensity to pay. Even if you valued Whatsapp by Facebook's P/E ratio of 87.74, it would have to make ~$215M/year in net profit to justify the (original) $19 billion price tag. That's around $0.50/user/year in net profits. I just don't see it ever happening.
- s_baby 12y agoIt's popular in emerging markets. Maybe it won't be worthless in 10 years. I still don't get the price. WhatsApp doesn't have the market cornered. There are 2-3 competitors and most locals I've met use all of them.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> most of whom are in countries viewed as almost worthless by advertisers Facebook is presumably making the bet that eventually those countries will no longer be deemed worthless by advertisers.
- s3r3nity 12y agoIt's myopic to think that anything/everything they do is advertiser driven. If you think of Facebook's goal as to "connect the world," and with such a large user base on WhatsApp, you can imagine that all WA needed to do was add a profile feature, and BAM - legitimate Facebook contender. It's why I think FB is nervous now that Twitter's profiles look a tad like FB timelines...the boundary is now a bit blurred.
- tdicola 12y agoFacebook is a public company now, their goal is to generate value for their shareholders. All other goals like 'connect the world' are secondary.
- 12y ago
- khazarboy123 12y agoThis article creates a fictitious binary world and then makes arguments within its nonsense universe. Take this quote: "Investors appear unfazed by the willingness of its founder, Mark Zuckerberg, to make huge bets on money-losing companies, instead trusting Silicon Valley logic over conventional measures of corporate worth." David Gelles also says that facebook values "users before profits." He's trying to create a binary world where silicon valley does one thing and the rest of the world does the "conventional" thing with the implication that silicon valley is stupid. While we know there may be a tradeoff between the users and profits they are definitely not mutually exclusive. There is no "conventional" logic versus some special "silicon valley logic" there is only "logic" and smart decisions, the foundation of all good business. Users today drive profits tomorrow. Another thought: by the time some logic has become conventional and commonplace is it not outdated? Recognizing unique opportunities that no one else sees seems to be the basis for all successful companies in and outside of silicon valley.
- segmondy 12y agoA lot of people are missing the point, citing the income WhatsApp has to make for Facebook to make back the money. What they forget is that WhatsApp was able to serve almost half a billion users with "minimal" hardware. That's what Facebook wants, Facebook will save a lot of money if they can be as efficient as WhatsApp in terms of hardware savings, engineer ratio user ratio. I would imagine that's Mark is aiming for.
- mertd 12y agoWhatsApp is/was an XMPP client in disguise. Facebook sits on top of different data at a different scale with a different problem definition.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoFacebook was removing a potential competitor from the market, just like they did with Instagram.
- zaqokm 12y agoThey bought a massive customer base in developing countries, and they manage to secure all of those users who use a messaging app without probably doing any deals with any telcos. Not only that, they gained a potential advantage in the payments space. Potentially turning their users into being able to make payments within the facebook & partners networks. Look at what is happening in China with companies turning their chat apps into taxi booking apps like WeChat.