5 ms·
It's bad. I recently drove to LA through the central valley, and in 18 years of doing that drive, I've never seen it so dry. Whole farms are just gone, everyt
by jedberg 12y ago
It's bad. I recently drove to LA through the central valley, and in 18 years of doing that drive, I've never seen it so dry. Whole farms are just gone, everything is brown.
There are a couple of problems preventing us from saving more water though.
#1, we had a drought in the 80s. A lot of people learned to conserve then and never changed their habits (like me). There is no way I could use 20% less water -- I already use the minimum. I have buckets all over the house for reuse, for example. My next step is a gray water system, which is expensive.
Which leads to #2, water is way to cheap in this state. I would have expected my water bill to go up during the drought. It's gone down. It's insane. Sure, let's keep tier one usage cheap so we don't destroy the poor, but tier two and up? It should be 10x what it is. That would make people conserve.
- function_seven 12y agoThis is what I don't get about the way this is being handled. Instead of threatening $500 fines for people whose neighbors rat them out, why don't they price water to its true cost¹? I guarantee consumption would plummet if the consumer had to pay for it. ¹Sure, there probably still needs to be variances for residential vs. agricultural use, and tier 1 vs. 2+, etc.
- jedberg 12y agoYes! That is what I am saying. I feel for the poor and the farmers, and I'm totally fine with paying more so they can pay less. I know I won't pay much more because I conserve, but the asshat down the street who waters the sidewalk will pay a lot more and I'm ok with that too.
- pdq 12y agoPoliticians, like most of the public, prefer to believe they have power over markets, and will use top-down rationing, rather than market-based pricing. See the gas/oil shortages of the 1970's, vs letting the market choose the price and having supply/demand automatically equalize based on price. Also, some of the officials making the rules on water restrictions are guzzlers themselves [1]. 1. http://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/california/California-Water-Officials-Arent-Following-Own-Call-for-Conservation-279304532.html http://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/california/California-Water-...
- spikels 12y agoDomestic water is probably overpriced not underpriced. It's the farmers who pay way too little (often zero!) for water. This has created screwed up incentives for farmers. Many crops are worth less than the true cost of the water needed to grow them! This is what happens when you have a system driven by politics and not the market - it's prone to lose touch with reality (actual cost/value). Unfortunately it will be very difficult to get back to prices based on actual costs - smaller number of big losers (some farmers) and lots of small winners (consumers & taxpayers) as well as tons of interlocking, inflexible regulations and subsidies (local, state & federal).
- akoncius 12y agofood industry should be partly subsidized by government, otherwise country could end up in trouble when people don't get enough neccessary basic food and stuff
- raldi 12y agoYes, the federal government.
- tomohawk 12y agoI would appear that the current subsidies are leading to an actual shortage of water.
- prostoalex 12y agoOr they could just buy it from another country, like thousands of basic food items we don't grow enough of, starting with rice and bananas.
- meeks 12y agoThe number 1 way to conserve water is to eat less meat. I don't think that people have learned this yet and most people have not changed their habits to consume less meat. Serious question: why is it acceptable to change all kinds of behaviors, take shorter showers, fix leaks, turn off taps, and even install gray water systems, yet not change our behavior to eat less meat? If you didn't eat beef for one day (1/2 lb beef = 1,250 gallons of fresh water) it could be the same as not showering for a month. Sources: http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/farm-practices-management/irrigation-water-use/background.aspx http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/farm-practices-management/irr... http://www.ewg.org/meateatersguide/interactive-graphic/water/ http://www.ewg.org/meateatersguide/interactive-graphic/water...
- Terr_ 12y ago> The number 1 way to conserve water is to eat less meat. Sure, but that's more of a global issue than a local one, insofar as meat (and food for livestock) is shipped much further than water is.
- tghw 12y agoCalifornia produced about 2 billion pounds of beef last year. That comes out to 8% of the US market for beef, the vast majority of which comes from the US. The numbers I found said that each pound of beef requires anywhere between 1000 and 5000 gallons of water. (I suspect the high end is probably too high, so let's go with the low end.) That gives us 2 trillion gallons of water used in California each year for beef production. Back of the napkin: If 10% of people who get their beef from California replace it chicken (which uses about a half the water per pound, both are about 1,000 calories per pound), the state would save 100 billion gallons of water per year. That's about 3 days worth of water for the whole state. (Apologies for lack of sources, I didn't realize this would turn into a research piece, so I didn't save them, but they seemed reputable.)
- Terr_ 12y agoThanks for that, but I think it somewhat misses the point. The demand-side of "everyone wants meat" problem is more of a long-term global-trends sustainability thing. The California issue is that the cost of locally-used water is not being reflected in locally-produced meat. People don't necessarily have to eat less meat in general, as long as less of the production comes specifically from California.
- pstuart 12y agoA classic, Forget Shorter Showers: http://www.orionmagazine.org/index.php/articles/article/4801/ http://www.orionmagazine.org/index.php/articles/article/4801...