4 ms·
I think you're misunderstanding what "network effects" means. A product or service benefits from the network effect when it becomes more useful the more users i
by ForHackernews 12y ago
I think you're misunderstanding what "network effects" means. A product or service benefits from the network effect when it becomes more useful the more users it has.
For example, a telephone by itself is completely worthless. A telephone when all your friends also have telephones is great.
Uber doesn't benefit from this effect in any meaningful way. If my friends all use Uber, that doesn't make Uber inherently more useful to me than Lyft (or a cab). Its utility is divorced from the number of other people using it.
What you're talking about is more properly called "mindshare" (much as I hate that term) or simply "consumer awareness".
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWell, if Uber isn't used then there aren't any cabs when I want one. Lots of people use UBer => I can always get a ride. SO that example might not be a good one.
- potatolicious 12y agoYou need to look at it the other way - it's really a two-headed network effect: there are two classes of users, drivers and riders. The more drivers they have the more useful it is to riders. There more riders they have the more useful it is to drivers. Whether this is sufficiently far from the original meaning of "network effect" that we need another name for it, maybe. Given how obvious this effect is, is there an existing name already for it? This isn't particularly new nor unique to technology. This is the entrenching effect you see in all exchanges - the stock exchange, eBay, etc... any clearing house for sellers and buyers to meet will benefit from this effect. I don't think "mindshare" is the right word for this.
- ForHackernews 12y ago> Given how obvious this effect is, is there an existing name already for it? It's a marketplace. As a seller, and a buyer, you generally benefit from going to a larger marketplace. But that analogy breaks down for ride-sharing because there's nothing preventing drivers from being simultaneously available on multiple ridesharing services, and it's trivially easy to switch between them. So there isn't any true isolation between different services, and it makes more sense to think of them as part of a single, larger ride-sharing marketplace.
- SilasX 12y ago>Uber doesn't benefit from this effect in any meaningful way. If my friends all use Uber, that doesn't make Uber inherently more useful to me than Lyft (or a cab). Its utility is totally divorced from the number of other people using it. True for the general model, but IIRC they're adding (or have added) features that do exploit network effects: - The fare-splitting feature [1] gets more useful as more of your friends have Uber. - The carpool service [2] will be more economical the more people you can find on the same route. [1] http://blog.uber.com/2013/07/15/faresplit/ http://blog.uber.com/2013/07/15/faresplit/ [2] http://blog.uber.com/uberpool http://blog.uber.com/uberpool
- ForHackernews 12y agoThose are much better examples of where network effects would come into play.
- acchow 12y ago> Uber doesn't benefit from this effect in any meaningful way. If my friends all use Uber, that doesn't make Uber inherently more useful to me than Lyft (or a cab). Its utility is totally divorced from the number of other people using it. The larger the rider base, the more drivers the service will have. Higher driver density certainly leads to a better product. Ebay experienced something similar.