3 ms·
Very well said. I would like to add a note, though, that "do your homework and then come back" can also be deployed dishonestly. Something I called out a bit
by dllthomas 12y ago
Very well said.
I would like to add a note, though, that "do your homework and then come back" can also be deployed dishonestly.
Something I called out a bit back (which was graciously received by the perpetrator - I don't think it was actually intentional in that instance) amounted to "If you haven't found the thing that proves I'm right, you haven't done enough homework". Which is an approach that can be rhetorically effective when people don't notice what you're doing, but seems somewhat poisonous to the goals of truth seeking, of educating ourselves, and of getting along.
I don't know the best way to distinguish these - most examples don't reduce so clearly and I agree there are plenty of cases where someone just needs to go read something.