3 ms·
I am not entirely sure I agree with you that reality is the master and mathematics, the servant - or that it's basically a human construction like language. For
by dTal 12y ago
I am not entirely sure I agree with you that reality is the master and mathematics, the servant - or that it's basically a human construction like language. For a start, you don't invent new mathematics - you discover it. You can't discover language. There's a strong sense when you look at things like the Mandelbrot set that mathematics is in some sense already "out there". What constrains maths is consistency - it is the study of inevitable consequences. Assuming that the laws of reality are indeed consistent (see hackinthebochs's comment for an argument to why they must be), this makes it a branch of mathematics. At this point considering the branch of mathematics that we personally can observe somehow more "real", in some vaguely-defined cosmic sense, is multiplying entities unnecessarily.
I don't think it has "rough edges" either. If your equations don't predict the world well, it doesn't mean that they are bad mathematics, or that the world is "wrong". You're just misapplying them.
As an aside, that Chomsky poem is the most beautiful thing I've read all week.
- dllthomas 12y ago"As an aside, that Chomsky poem is the most beautiful thing I've read all week." To clarify (unsure whether or not you understand this): "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously" was picked by Chomsky as a nonsense phrase that he asserted had no meaning despite being syntactically correct. That was an aside from his actual use of the phrase, which was to demonstrate that there is in fact something that we see as "grammatical" in even novel sentences that play by the rules - the point of the sentence was that it had not been uttered before. This was in the space of an argument at the time of whether we deem things grammatical because they are sensical, or deem things grammatical because we have encountered them before. I don't know offhand whether this was used directly as evidence or as pedagogy (certainly, I first encountered it in pedagogical context) but it makes it pretty clear that it cannot be the latter and it probably isn't the former, and we're really recognizing some deeper structure. A lot of this is more obvious to we who've been playing with compilers for ages - though I am only moderately confident that this "obvious" result is actually correct. Coming back... the first half of the quoted sentence is someone else's work, trying to place Chomsky's "nonsense" sentence in a situation where it has a meaning. I'm not convinced it was successful - I think it plays with mood rather than meaning. Regardless, that's the context...
- dTal 12y agoThanks - I was aware that the sentence was selected because it was syntactically valid but semantic nonsense, but not so familiar with the background debate. For what it's worth, I do think the poem was successful at extracting meaning from each word, albeit metaphorical. It clearly refers to hibernating seeds: "Colorless" refers to the embryonic nature of the seeds - seeds are indeed white or transparent. "Green ideas" are obviously biochemical ambitions for the future - the seeds do not want to be colorless forever. "Sleep furiously" - they may be hibernating, but they are alive and raring to go! I was so tickled because even without the background, I thought it was good enough poetry to stand on its own. For what it's worth, I believe conveying mood counts as meaning anyway, but in this case I think the poem is surprisingly coherent and specific.
- dllthomas 12y agoAh, I'd missed that interpretation. Well done.
- Retric 12y agoYou can easily write a program to list every possible book in every language. What your describing has more to do with how we create a book or a proof vs what actually exists.
- dllthomas 12y agoYou can trivially write a program to list every possible book in every language, but only if it also lists a whole bunch of books that are not in any language. That seems like it might be important. (It's certainly important to many arguments, I'm not entirely sure it's important to this one).
- Retric 12y agoConsidering the same thing apply's to math books, I am not really sure there is a difference. Basically, if you don't mind listing math proofs with errors it's a much easier exercise. In the end Math has a more restrictive syntax, but it's just as valid to prove say X+44.217 > X vs X + 1 > X. So the 'elegance' of math IMO has more to do with us selecting for it vs some innate property. Or to get back to the parent's argument about the Mandelbrot set, you can draw plenty of pictures with Math. The tiny fraction of equations that are both simple and cool looking are what we select for. Worse, the equation works just fine in black and white we add false color and select for a small subset of the space that's interesting all of which is designed to make pretty pictures, and then say look how many 'simple' math equations make pretty pictures. Despite the fact it takes a fair amount of code for the equation to end up looking like that.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoYou invent the definitions from which you discover the theorems.