3 ms·
>> But what seems absolutely impossible to me is that we have different correct theories, i.e. they describe nature flawlessly where they apply, but they noneth
by phkahler 12y ago
>> But what seems absolutely impossible to me is that we have different correct theories, i.e. they describe nature flawlessly where they apply, but they nonetheless lead to inconsistencies or contradictions.
But isn't that exactly where we are with quantum mechanics and relativity? Everyone thinks that if we were smarter or given more time, a unified theory will emerge that looks like one or the other at the appropriate scale. What if that never happens? I think the author is asking "What if that's not even possible?". It seems possible to him because there is no known reason for the mathematics to fit the world in the first place.
- danbruc 12y agoNo, we know that neither relativity nor quantum mechanics is correct, so the premise is already not fulfilled. And, as I said, too, it is very possible that we or mathematics fails to give a unified and correct description. But I just read the part again and I probably misread it the first time. He is not talking about having absolutely correct but inconsistent or contradicting theories, but about theories that are correct, consistent and non-contradicting where we can test them and maybe even where we can ever expect to test them, but ultimately lead to inconsistencies or contradictions if we extrapolate them beyond experimental reach. This leaves us in a situation where the theories are in perfect agreement with reality but on purely theoretical grounds it seems impossible that they are correct. This is more similar to the situation of relativity and quantum mechanics but we have not yet reached the experimental limits and the theories are not even in perfect agreement with all available data. (I will read it a third time, I am still not totally convinced that I got it right.)