3 ms·
"GOTV activists might be in a better position to assist people lacking valid ID than the individuals themselves." It would be quite a nice consequence of all t
by dllthomas 12y ago
"GOTV activists might be in a better position to assist people lacking valid ID than the individuals themselves."
It would be quite a nice consequence of all this if it meant we found people an incentive to help their fellow citizen get their papers in order. It's a bit disheartening we have papers that need to be in order, but I'm not convinced it's meaningfully avoidable. I'm a bit worried that the incentives might wind up weird, though, in some way we're not anticipating.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI honestly don't think it could be worse. The incentives already seem quite weird to me - in Europe we don't typically have paid signature gatherers trying to petition people on the street and register them to vote. I find it very easy to see how people who are here illegally or who are here legally but not entitled to vote might end up being registered to vote by accident - I nearly (and criminally) registered to vote years ago while I was signing some innocuous-seeming petition to save whales or something like that in the middle of the street. At the time I hadn't been in the US very long, maybe a year? It was only because I'm the sort of pedant who reads the fine print on everything, even TV adverts, that I noticed the boilerplate text at the bottom of the form about how I would be breaking the law if registered to vote without being entitled. A lot of people just follow the instructions of the signature-gatherer, and those persons are a) paid by the number of people they sign up and b) not necessarily so well-informed that they realize the significance of the legal problems that illegal registration can cause for the registrant. It's a bit disheartening we have papers that need to be in order Agreed, and I don't think you should have to carry ID if you're not voting/driving/engaged in something which can materially impact others. But in a complex modern economy, government-as-ID-provider is about the nearest thing we have to a neutral honest broker, so I also agree it's unavoidable as a practical issue.
- dllthomas 12y agoIt always could be worse; I didn't say I was significantly worried, I just think it's something to keep an eye on. Incentives are often surprising. I certainly agree that there are already some pretty screwy ones.