2 ms·
The main goals of these "hints" is to 1) Release the information to the public. 2) Not be on the official record of releasing such information. Maybe Justice
by rdtsc 12y ago
The main goals of these "hints" is to
1) Release the information to the public.
2) Not be on the official record of releasing such information.
Maybe Justice Dept. doesn't want to be on the record about not towing the party line or not being "tough" on leakers, but at the same time, it perceives the public is getting a little fed up with these NSA shenanigans. So they don't want to make it official, as it would seem as the executive branch is devided in its public stance.
So they test the waters by releaseing an "anonymous" hint like that and then see what happens.
This also, interestingly, can serve as a hint-hint to the NSA management to tone it down a bit, as Obama is getting some bad rap about this and so on. Sometimes the most direct message is not a direct message but through an anonymous hint like this. (Directed both at media, people but also government agencies as well).
This is nothing new and is tried and true PR technique.
- sarciszewski 12y agoAre there any ongoing efforts to disrupt PR schemes like this? I'd like to see the public less easily manipulated but I'm not sure where to start. (And, technically, not sure that I'm not also being manipulated.)
- rayiner 12y agoI don't think this amounts to manipulation of the public, since it's an attempt to get truthful information out into the public. Rather it's politics--like getting your friend to ask someone else's friend if she likes you. People on HN tend to frown on this sort of politics. I'd posit that such attitudes are counter-productive. If you forced Americans to choose between two black or white options: security or liberty, you might very well not like the outcome. Sympathy towards people who leak national security information is not such a popular position that an agency can shout it from the rooftops. If you make more subtle disclosures untenable, the outcome might not work out in your favor.
- sarciszewski 12y agoSorry, I should have clarified: Any tool or technique can (will?) be employed by either side. I moreso wanted to know: when the security > liberty fanatics employ it against us, how can we best disrupt it?
- alexqgb 12y agoThere's also a problem with hardline Conservatives who see Snowden as a out-and-out traitor, don't see a major problem with a heavily police-friendly state, and are generally looking for any means to bash the President for not being "tough enough" with "the bad guys". This can be a good way of saying what lot of people need and want to hear without giving the poo-flinging trolls a clear target for their displeasure.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]