3 ms·
I don't see where owenmarshall said that "illegal voting" was a non-issue. They said that there was no issue with "one type of potential fraud: I go to the pol
by dllthomas 12y ago
I don't see where owenmarshall said that "illegal voting" was a non-issue. They said that there was no issue with "one type of potential fraud: I go to the polls and impersonate someone else", that there were few "instances of in-person vote fraud that would've been prevented by requiring ID at the polls", and that "there's still no real evidence to indicate that requiring an ID would make a real impact." All of that seems to jive with the article.
I see how your comment may not have been advocating voter id, but then I don't see what you were actually objecting to. I apologize for reading more into your comment than was there, but I'd welcome clarification.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWell, I said in the very first sentence that relying on the data in a 2012 article to articulate the scope of illegal voting was pointless. The previous conventional wisdom was that the known instances of illegal voting were in the mere dozens, which is negligible compared to the hundreds of thousands known to lack ID who might be unjustly disenfranchised by ID requirements. But this new evidence suggests that the incidence of illegal voting is several orders of magnitude greater than previously thought. In passing (which I should have mentioned earlier) Remember that voter ID laws only tackle one type of potential fraud: I go to the polls and impersonate someone else. is incorrect. It can also act as proof that someone who registered without being entitled to vote did in fact vote. Registering to vote when you're not entitled to do so is a federal offense, as is actually voting, but obviously only the latter affects the outcome of elections (which is why it's such a political football). Well, registering indirectly affects elections insofar as it affects the way congressional districts are organized, but the marginal impact of illegal registration is much lower than the marginal impact of illegal voting.
- dllthomas 12y agoYour first paragraph makes the same mistake your original comment did - the comment was not speaking to all instances of illegal voting but specifically what might be addressable by voter id laws. Your second paragraph is more interesting, and does in fact address owenmarshall's original comment. You're asserting that requiring id serves an evidentiary purpose and therefore allows stricter enforcement? It is an interesting theory, but I am skeptical that it is either necessary or sufficient - sending someone to jail because a poll worker says they saw their ID is scary (ID could have been forged, poll worker could be in error, &c). It could still possibly be a component of something more useful, but clearly the concerns about legitimate voters who lack ID should be addressed somehow.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI made my comment about one particular aspect of his argument. I'm frankly rather irritated with your and his insistence that I should structure my arguments to suit someone else's point of view rather than the part I found particularly interesting. It was never my intention to refute his entire argument, just to point out that one aspect of it was flawed.
- dllthomas 12y agoIt's not that you should structure your arguments to suit someone else's point of view, but rather that you should structure your argument such that it is clear what you are disagreeing with. Particularly if you are going to be as hostile as you were in your opening comment. You accused him of "ignoring the results of this new study", acting "disingenuous at best", when what he said was well in line with both the new study and the old article. That is what I was objecting to. If both the new study and the old article and his thinking share an error - which possibility is suggested by your latest point - then raising that is interesting and useful. But it is not indicative of his being disingenuous or "ignoring data [he doesn't] like". (Arguably his latest comment is doing a little bit of that last, though being sure you catch everything gets harder when one feels unjustly attacked).
- anigbrowl 12y agoObviously we don't agree about this, but I'd point out again that I stated what it was that I was disagreeing with very explicitly in the first paragraph of my original reply. If you look at the last paragraph of the Atlantic article (on page 2), it comments on the very low number of verified incidents (resulting in a conviction). I do think it's disingenuous and self-defeating to cite a story like that without addressing the new information, even though he cited it for a different purpose (pointing to the much higher # of people without an ID). The whole premise of the story is that the possibility for disenfranchisement is massively worse than the possibility of fraud, since the ratio of people without suitable ID to fraudulent voters is ~10,000:1. ISTM to that when one has new information which appears to significantly undermine that premise, it's very important to qualify the citation. It's true my tone was a bit hostile, but as someone inclined to support Democratic policies I'm extremely frustrated by democrats' seeming inability to hold a rational discussion of the topic, in the same way that moderate Republicans must often feel frustrated with some of the tropes that prevail on the right wing of their party and which cost votes at election time.
- owenmarshall 12y ago> In passing (which I should have mentioned earlier) Remember that voter ID laws only tackle one type of potential fraud: I go to the polls and impersonate someone else. is incorrect. It can also act as proof that someone who registered without being entitled to vote did in fact vote. That shouldn't be "in passing" - that's the whole thrust of your argument! It's also a bit odd, because once again, voter ID plays a negligible part in it. If I, owenmarshall, was born in Notamericastan and am not a citizen, yet I register and vote in an election, the act of me actually voting is sufficient proof that I, a citizen of Notamericastan, committed voter fraud. How does requiring an ID provide any additional proof that the person voted? The fact that I signed my name and received a ballot is prima facie sufficient to demonstrate that. > But this new evidence suggests that the incidence of illegal voting is several orders of magnitude greater than previously thought. It demonstrates that requiring photo ID to vote is ineffective: "Nearly three quarters of the non-citizens who indicated they were asked to provide photo identification at the polls claimed to have subsequently voted." (from the article we are literally discussing now.) > The previous conventional wisdom was that the known instances of illegal voting were in the mere dozens, which is negligible compared to the hundreds of thousands known to lack ID who might be unjustly disenfranchised by ID requirements. It's also important to note this isn't the case: the conventional wisdom has always been that the known instances of illegal voting which could be reasonably addressed through voter ID requirements were in the mere dozens, negligible compared to the much larger body of legal voters who risk disenfranchisement. -- So conventional wisdom indicates illegal voting of a form that can be addressed by requiring photo ID is incredibly rare. This research indicates that requiring photo IDs is not a sufficient barrier to prevent illegal voters from voting - illegal voters apparently have a photo ID anyway. And the number of voters who risk disenfranchisement from photo ID requirements is still very high. So we agree that photo ID requirements are useless, right? ;-)
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat shouldn't be "in passing" - that's the whole thrust of your argument! No it isn't. IT's a completely separate observation. With all due respect, you don't get to decide what my argument is. It's also a bit odd, because once again, voter ID plays a negligible part in it. If I, owenmarshall, was born in Notamericastan and am not a citizen, yet I register and vote in an election, the act of me actually voting is sufficient proof that I, a citizen of Notamericastan, committed voter fraud. No it isn't. If challenged about this, in many states where the registration requirements are quite loose you could reasonably say 'some other person registered to vote using my name,' and it's difficult to prove otherwise. As you can see, registration requirements aren't consisitent from state to state and it's questionable how good of a job states do at verifying the citizenship status of registrants: http://www.eac.gov/assets/1/Documents/Federal%20Voter%20Registration_6-25-14_ENG.pdf http://www.eac.gov/assets/1/Documents/Federal%20Voter%20Regi... How does requiring an ID provide any additional proof that the person voted? The fact that I signed my name and received a ballot is prima facie sufficient to demonstrate that. Depends on how distinctive your signature is. It's also important to note this isn't the case: the conventional wisdom has always been that the known instances of illegal voting which could be reasonably addressed through voter ID requirements were in the mere dozens, negligible compared to the much larger body of legal voters who risk disenfranchisement. That's not true. You're rewriting the historical argument in order to avoid addressing new information. The conventional wisdom has been that known instances were in the mere dozens. Adding 'which could reasonably be addressed through voter ID requirements' is a misrepresentation of the anti-voter-ID position. So we agree that photo ID requirements are useless, right? ;-) No we don't, and I don't find your rhetorical contortions funny. While I don't think photo ID requirements are a remedy for the problem of illegal voting (for the reasons laid out in the article, with the primary problem being that many illegal voters aren't aware they're breaking the law and may even think they're doing the wright thing, the reason I'm arguing for consideration of voter ID is that it addresses the obviates the argument of people who argue that the electoral process is deliberately corrupted. I'm getting tired explaining this so I'm going to stop now. As I said earlier, Democrats would save themselves an awful lot of political capital if they stopped trying to rationalize the abundant flaws of the electoral registration system and instead focused their efforts on ensuring that disadvantaged citizens who lack valid photo ID were provided with it, which would bring disenfranchised people many significant benefits beyond that of exercising their electoral franchise.