3 ms·
> We need better safeguards within the regulatory framework to make sure this equipment does not fall into unlawful hands and, if it does, that the law provides
by Someone1234 12y ago
> We need better safeguards within the regulatory framework to make sure this equipment does not fall into unlawful hands and, if it does, that the law provides severe penalties to act as an effective deterrent.
That's "solution" is moronic and lazy.
Instead of changing the car's security systems so they're actually secure, you want to make the security obscure by making key-recoders illegal to even own?
Makes me wonder if this is even really about the thefts or the car manufacturers using the thefts as an excuse to push their competitors out of the market using this new proposed law. If authorised dealerships are the only people who can legally re-code cars/keys then they've just assured themselves a huge business boost.
Plus this law will be ineffective. There is already a law against owning tools designed to break into vehicles ("tools of the trade" laws). But they're largely ineffective at stopping vehicle crime.
Instead they should make the technology entirely transparent and hire some damn cryptographers to design their systems. Double public-key cryptography (e.g. one private key in the car and key-fob respectively) make doing this securely absolutely possible.
Set up an industry group who stores the car's private keys and allows any authorised shop to request them and update them. Store an audit log. If a car gets stolen pull the log and see who requested the private key, then send the bobbies around to sort 'em out.
- click170 12y agoMore succinctly, we already have laws against stealing cars but people still do it. I agree the locks need to be stronger. Perhaps it needs to be an independent third party that tests, breaks, and publicly reviews keyless entry systems. Such a third party could provide "certification" or badges for Cryptographically Secure Keyless Entry systems. When purchasing a vehicle I'd be willing to pay a small premium for a vehicle with secure locks.
- bobbles 12y agoSounds like Apple should start licencing out Touch ID to car companies
- castis 12y agoAnd then make it illegal to own the documentation if you lack the rights so it doesn't fall into the wrong hands.
- floatrock 12y ago> If authorised dealerships are the only people who can legally re-code cars/keys then they've just assured themselves a huge business boost. One of the neat ideas that, imho, doesn't receive nearly enough attention in the bitcoin space is smart property -- you can use the blockchain and cryptography to have decentralized property transfer, even offline and in a hostile network environment (ie a thief trying to spoof a property transfer message to the car. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Smart_Property#Theory https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Smart_Property#Theory lists the gorey crypto-details, but imagine instead of transferring ownership, you just temporarily grant another party (ie your mechanic) to have 'ownership-like' rights to your car while it's in the shop. > Set up an industry group who stores the car's private keys and allows any authorised shop to request them... Centralized points of failure always fail. How long before the next Target or Home Depot has a credit card breach? How long before this centralized authority blocks non-dealer shops from being part of the network (or pay exorbitant fees). We can decentralize all this while still keeping it cryptographically secure.
- gnopgnip 12y agoWhat happens when you lose a key?
- floatrock 12y agoExactly one of the major issues blocking consumer-level adoption of decentralization technologies. Centralized trust is just too darn convenient, especially wrt backups. As with most ideological debates, the middle ground is probably the most amicable. Bigger crypto-nerds than me will have more fleshed out ideas, I'm sure, but there are ways to have a hybrid centralized/decentralized approach. One algorithm I've heard tossed around, for example, is shamir's secret sharing. Basically you can split a key between different parties... no one party/dealer/mechanic/DMV has access to the family jewels, but you can reconstruct the secret with 3 of the 5 pieces or whatever threshold. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir's_Secret_Sharing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir's_Secret_Sharing The challenge is, like you say, to make all this magic enough that it becomes consumer friendly. Much more fulfilling a UX gig than designing virtual farms, though.
- 12y ago