5 ms·
The proposed solution: "societal pressure". That certainly seems innocuous enough. But online harassers are a tiny group already-marginalized people (asserting
by mindslight 12y ago
The proposed solution: "societal pressure". That certainly seems innocuous enough. But online harassers are a tiny group already-marginalized people (asserting otherwise is willfully ignoring obvious numbers, and that should make anybody wary). Increasing the scorn is not going to change them! When this approach inevitably fails, then this same "societal pressure" will be parlayed into the newly-created common wisdom of outright censorship of the Internet.
- talmand 12y agoI would agree increasing the scorn is likely to have the opposite effect. It would seem these type of people feed off such things. Increasing the level of response, even if it is negative, will only further one of the goals of the harassers; getting the attention of people while they commit the harassment. Anonymous-based movements on the Internet are just the feeding trough for these type of people, regardless of the alleged motives of the movement.
- chillingeffect 12y agoThe article likens societal pressure to sexual harassment in the workplace. However, the power structure is not the same. In the workplace, bosses/admins had to be convinced to treat the problem different, then the wielded the power to make people cooperate. Online harassment doesn't feature an authority figure who can cutoff the access of the harassers though. What is the solution? I don't know. I think the death threats are a result of the self-hatred and sense of disposession our consumer society creates. We are motivated by the fear of not having enough and therefore our primal minds are constantly threatened. The people at the bottom have little to lose and act out.
- tedks 12y ago>When this approach inevitably fails, then this same "societal pressure" will be parlayed into the new common wisdom of outright censorship of the Internet. I don't think it's possible to say that social pressure, or in other words, education, is definitely going to fail. Harassers are people. We need to teach boys that they are not, in fact, entitled to women's bodies, and hopefully then not just online harassment but also street harassment, sexual harassment, and sexual assault will decrease. But what's wrong with blocking 4chan, or gamergaters.com or whatever else? These are sites that are demonstratably, reliably causing people gross personal distress and sometimes egging people on into massive acts of violence. Notably, the UC Santa Barbara shooter was a 4chan member, and almost certainly was radicalized there. It's easy to say that "free speech" or "censorship-free internet" are good things; it's much harder to look at the actual statistics and realize that every post on 4chan is a little piece of an inevitable hate crime. The average is the total over the number; regardless of the small average contribution of each 4chan post to harassment and violence, the end result is GamerGate and mass murder. Ironically, when it comes to Muslims doing the same thing as white men on 4chan, the media and hacker news is united in wanting to shut down "radical Islamist forums." At the end of the day, you have to decide what's more important: an internet where no website is blocked, or the safety of women. If you decide the former, you are every bit as responsible for the deaths of women as the people who physically pull the trigger, because you said nothing and did nothing when you could have stopped the root cause. As another point, there is massive value to the survivors in making it absolutely clear that what happened to them is not okay; that they did not deserve it; that they should be outraged and that the perpetrators, when caught, will be punished and ostracized. The only way to do this is by actually condemning, punishing, and ostracizing perpetrators. The benefits of solidarity are very real; women who experience victim-blaming after sexual assault have vastly higher rates of PTSD. So societal pressure in favor of feminism and away from male entitlement seems like a fine way to address this problem, and if it leads to the death of websites that organize harassment campaigns so much the better.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoAll fine in principle. But can you really kill a website? The internet is as close to be an ideal marketplace of ideas as we've ever gotten. What's suppressed in one place will thrive in another. Its not wrong to want to suppress hate speech; its not misguided to suppress radicalization of young people. Its also unlikely that 'shutting down websites' will succeed at either of those.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoI agree wholeheartedly. 4chan is a menace that directly leads to mass murder and GamerGate. Just look at these mass murderers in training over at /ck/: https://boards.4chan.org/ck/ https://boards.4chan.org/ck/ Absolutely horrific. Every post over there is a little piece of an inevitable hate crime. The safety of women is too important to let them get away. Apologies for being blunt and sardonic, but seriously? Your preconceptions of 4chan are so horribly skewed and your saying that the UC Barbara shooter was a 4chan reader is an incredibly stupid justification. I'm sure Facebook radicalizes people every day. Ban Facebook?
- tedks 12y agoI'm not going to click that link, I'm sorry. I don't know what perverse topic /ck/ pertains to but there's no way it'd be good for me. It's a fact that 4chan is directly related to harassment and mass murder. I don't know why you'd dispute this unless you agreed with it.
- mindslight 12y agoIt seems you were right. I impulsively clicked that link and was promptly greeted with several graphic pictures celebrating murder. But still I'm wise enough to understand that I will never convince anyone to become vegetarian by preaching at them or controlling their discussion.
- tedks 12y agoBet you could make a lot of people vegetarian by banning slaughterhouses. That's what 4chan is. It's a memetic slaughterhouse.