7 ms·
Feds identify suspected 'second leaker' for Snowden reporters
- matthewmcg 12y ago"But the case has also generated concerns among some within the U.S. intelligence community that top Justice Department officials — stung by criticism that they have been overzealous in pursuing leak cases — may now be more reluctant to bring criminal charges involving unauthorized disclosures to the news media, the sources said. One source, who asked not to be identified because of the sensitivity of the matter, said there was concern 'there is no longer an appetite at Justice for these cases.'" Aren't these comments themselves probably unauthorized disclosures to the news media?
- privong 12y ago> Aren't these comments themselves probably unauthorized disclosures to the news media? Offically, yes. In practice, no. My understanding is that government orgs need some amount of non-official contact with journalists in order to get information out to the public. That is partly so they can make favorable information disclosures without it seeming official. One could view the comment you quoted as an attempt to slightly improve the image of the Justice Dept and intelligence community without risking those entities appearing to be "soft on crime" (which is what would likely happen if they issued an official statment).
- x0x0 12y agoassuming that the comments are those that the directors of the nsa or cia like, then it's an authorized disclosure. Only the delusional would view either org as soft on leakers.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bediger4000 12y agoWhoa whoa whoa! Now we're getting deep into what used to be called "Kremlinology". Back in the depths of the Cold War (and even today, from North Korea) the Soviet government would issue "news" that was blatantly untrue manure, and nothing else. So people would try to divine real meaning from arcane aspects of the untrue manure. If they need to "make favorable information disclosures without it seeming official", and they need to improve their image without appearing to be "soft on crime", they should just say so, rather than making unofficial official statements and jumping through flaming semantics hoops like linguistic circus lions. We know those TLAs are rogue, but if we need to apply Kremlinology to understand them, they've lost their moral and linguistic anchors as well.
- mpyne 12y agoExcept that leaks to the press as a way of trying to control a story (or to simply play bureaucratic knife fights) is a DC art as old as time. Such things happen in other countries including Russia, though the Kremlin promulgating "blatantly untrue" material isn't quite the same as leaking stories to the press...
- bediger4000 12y agoExcept that these unofficial official leaks are now in the Sacred Homeland Security arena! Think of the children! Terrorist must not triumph! If you give them an inch they'll abuse a mile of it right into the ground! Seriously, off the record stuff about unemployment statistics is one thing. Leaking stuff about drones and TSA and so forth is entirely another, or so we're told. Isn't James Risen in the doghouse over exactly that sort of thing?
- frandroid 12y ago> they've lost their moral and linguistic anchors as well. Whoa whoa whoa, I thought the intelligence apparatus was a benevolent entity!
- privong 12y agoI was not justifying their method (or even saying that the unofficial/unauthorized leaks were truthful), merely offering a possible explanation of why they are allowed to happen (or, likely, encouraged). When I said "favorable information disclosures", I meant favorable to the agency involved, not necessarily to anybody else.
- jessaustin 12y agoAfter reading enough of these unchallenged self-serving not-responsible-for-deliberate-lies voice-of-pretend-authority that's-not-piss-in-your-ear-it's-rain official-unofficial off-the-record comments, one concludes that they never have an ounce of truth to them, so the parties that theoretically would care about unauthorized disclosures are right to ignore them completely. [EDIT] Wow, there must be a bunch of "journalists" on HN! Never mind me, just go back to parroting exactly what TPTB tell you, but not for attribution, so that none of the lies you tell on their behalf can be challenged.
- colordrops 12y agoBesides the content of your post, you are being downvoted because your comment is nearly impossible to parse and comes off as pretentious. Grammatically standard English would serve better to get your point across.
- alexbecker 12y agoFewer hyphens might also be in order.
- ephemeralgomi 12y agoI thought it was a TempleOS post at first.
- jessaustin 12y agoHahaha well that's an accomplishment of sorts. b^)
- smsm42 12y agoI guess there are different types. Telling journalists water-cooler rumors and generics is one thing, leaking them classified docs is another. The latter probably is pursued much more vigorously than the first, even though technically the first may be policy violation too.
- pessimizer 12y ago"Unnamed sources" can usually be considered officially floated statements when coming from any major media outlet. If major news organizations printed anonymous sources in the administration saying things both that 1) didn't have any component that can be factually verified and 2) were not something that the administration wanted to release, they'd find themselves in enough trouble enough of the time that it would become difficult to do their jobs or stay profitable. edit: they're really not anything that actual journalists should be including in their stories. Sadly, these quotes from unnamed sources are often the entire story.
- drewcrawford 12y agoThis is probably a trial balloon [1], a tactic of leaking information in order to gauge the reaction. For a long time in US foreign crime/terrorism policy there has been a sense of "find our enemies, no matter where they are, no matter the cost." Changing that positioning would be a big U-turn in rhetoric. By floating this change under the guise of "sources close to the matter", they get to gauge the reaction of interested parties while maintaining cover of deniability if it's poorly-received. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_balloon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_balloon
- MichaelMoser123 12y agois yahoo.com good enough to function as a trial baloon (does this publication have access to effective actors, does it have enough clout), or do you need the New York Times for that?
- arh68 12y agoYes, but the classification laws were always known to apply to pawns. The rules don't matter higher up, they never have. Use of force trickles down, not up. If you were in power, would you really limit your propaganda to what's publicly known? What could possibly be the repercussion of selectively leaking to your advantage?
- ripb 12y ago>"The Obama administration in my view is conducting a war against whistleblowers and ultimately against independent journalism." This is spot on. When you use your power to ground another President's flight in the hope of catching a whistleblower from your own country on it, there is something very wrong.
- sarciszewski 12y agoI'm always amazed that most people don't know about this incident.
- le_hackour 12y agoIn America, this kind of thing is hidden in fine print.
- sarciszewski 12y ago@le_hackour said (and their post was insta-killed): > In America, this kind of thing is hidden in fine print. This needs to be unhidden. Any spammers want to donate some of their resources to actually solving problems?
- sintaxi 12y agoWow, I had no idea that happened. Here's a link for the lazy... http://antiwar.com/blog/2013/07/03/us-violates-intl-law-grounding-bolivian-presidents-plane-in-pursuit-of-snowden/ http://antiwar.com/blog/2013/07/03/us-violates-intl-law-grou...
- sarciszewski 12y agoWould it be considered topical enough to submit this to HN as a separate post? EDIT: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8519052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8519052
- rquantz 12y agoYes, it's pretty incredible. And try to imagine if a foreign power forced down air force 1 and boarded the plane. That would be an act of war.
- sarciszewski 12y agoIt's a shame they identified* the second leaker. I was hoping they would be able to leak moar. * Allegedly. Innocent until proven guilty. It'd be great if they managed to beat the government in court.
- par0xyzm 12y agoMaybe they haven't ;)
- par0xyzm 12y agoWhich band of government shills is downvoting anyone who doesn't side with the feds [pigs] on this one? Identify yourselves and sign up for pr0j3kt m4yh3m's next hit list whenever or whoever that may be
- gnu8 12y agoI hope the leaker is safe - the article doesn't say an arrest was made.
- sarciszewski 12y agoThis is an excellent point.
- ademarre 12y agoBruce Schneier insists this is actually the third leaker. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/10/us_intelligence.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/10/us_intelligen... https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/08/the_us_intellig.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/08/the_us_intell... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8150292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8150292
- par0xyzm 12y agoThe second leaker will become the "third" if they are identified after Snowden and the person in this story.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lovelearning 12y agoI'm curious why Greenwald and Schneier seem so keen to publicly conjecture that there are multiple whistleblowers. It seems rather counterproductive to me. Is there a good reason?
- INTPenis 12y agoInteresting that you would ask that because as I was reading the article I kept thinking that it's beneficial to the US government to stop prosecuting these things due to two reasons. 1) Maintaining a facade of complete denial. 2) Not giving credence to the idea that there were two people willing to rat out their government due to what they had seen, so as to maintain the possibility that it was just a lone rogue. But this is just my external perspective, as a european who never set foot on US soil.
- pgeorgi 12y agoAfter someone published Aug 2013 material, it was clear that Snowden isn't the only one. There's no harm in talking about two whistleblowers at that point. Emphasizing that there's more than one might encourage even more whistleblowers. Talking about a certain number might also hide that there are even _more_ out there. Knowing the exact number of sources might help the agencies assign publications to sources, and thus, support in locating them. If you try to assign material that is actually from five sources to just two, you'll have a hard time seeing a clear picture.