4 ms·
So having used a Polar heart rate monitor (the kind with the chest strap), I am used to the heart rate to be very accurately measured. The downside to the Polar
by IgorPartola 12y ago
So having used a Polar heart rate monitor (the kind with the chest strap), I am used to the heart rate to be very accurately measured. The downside to the Polar HRM is that I can't wear it 24/7. It'd be nice to see my HR all day long, but the strap is not comfortable for anything but actual workouts. The improved version of my HRM includes Bluetooth to connect to my phone, a GPS unit, and a large display that shows me where I'm going. It also includes things like connectivity to a cycle computer on an exercise bike, etc. All of this is still workout-only, but doesn't help with day to day stuff.
Now, the Charge HR and Surge promise the same thing without the chest strap. This sounds really appealing, and it's at a price point that's very competitive with the Polar and Garmin products. However, I doubt that it's that accurate. The reason is that I am sure that if the technology existed to get rid of the strap, by now Polar and Garmin would have been all over it. Remember, these companies are targeting people that are very serious about getting info about their workouts only. If they could deliver the same level of accuracy without the annoying chest strap, or even with the chest strap that you didn't have to use with electrode gel, they would.
What I suspect will happen is the same thing as happened with the previous iterations: you will get moderately accurate heart rate at rest, but when you start running, swimming, playing basketball, etc., the FitBit will not get a reading.
I'd love to be proven wrong. The moment I see serious fitness nerds jumping from Polar to FitBit, I'll join them. Until then, I remain skeptical.
- mikestew 12y ago> However, I doubt that it's that accurate. It's not that it's not accurate. In comparisons of two products (Samsung Gear Fit and an as-of-yet-unannounced product) with my Polar and Garmin straps, it seems to be close enough...when it works. And that's the trick, because if I can't consistently get it to work, then it effectively doesn't work at all. But if the strap isn't tight, forget it. And during exercise it just won't reliably give you HR regardless. Either it just gives up, or it tries to pretend that it worked when conditions were not optimal to get an accurate reading. > The moment I see serious fitness nerds jumping from Polar to FitBit, I'll join them. Until then, I remain skeptical. Serious fitness nerd here (well, just an obsessive runner, really) with a shelf full of Garmin and Polar devices. I doubt FitBit will ever even try to grab that market. If they do, they appear to lack the experience (and chops, for that matter) to pull off grabbing the 70 mile/week marathoner market (or serious triathlete, et. al.). It's a big jump from "inactive person who needs motivation to get off their ass" to "serious athlete who wants accurate telemetry presented in a useful manner". Even Garmin and Polar struggle with that, and they've been at it for years.
- IgorPartola 12y agoYes, I guess that's what I mean. For me, the Polar strap works 99% of the time. The times it stops working just need to wet it. I try to clean it well, and use the electrode gel to keep it working. It's messy, but worth knowing that my HRM is actually recording my workout. If Polar or Garmin had access to technology to make this messiness go away, I think they'd pounce on it. I don't think FitBit is big enough to innovate on something like that.
- dgacmu 12y agoBut the first company to crack getting HR affordably and reliably without a separate strap? Take my money! A watch that can do it well - in rain, freezing weather, with salty sweat, or sunshine - would be incredibly cool. The strap is by far the weakest link of Garmin and Polar watches.
- Osmium 12y ago> However, I doubt that it's that accurate. How accurate is accurate? As someone who works out casually, I'd be happy with something that gave even ± 10 bpm, because that'd be far more information than I currently have. If, however, as another poster speculated it's more of the case that it only works intermittently, then that's a deal breaker.
- IgorPartola 12y agoI think it'd be intermittent. The problem is that you move around too much when you work out. An simple electrical sensor needs constant contact with your skin to read your HR. If it comes loose, it won't give you a wrong reading, it'll give you no reading. This is the current state of the art. The optical HRM thing they are saying they have is likely to have the same problem. I doubt it'd give you bad data, just no data.
- Osmium 12y agoDo you think that'd be the case even if you tighten the strap significantly for a workout?
- IgorPartola 12y agoYes. It's not just good contact. It's about good electrical contact. For example, if the strap is dry, even if it's directly on the skin, it won't pick up a signal. I suspect that this optical LED-based HRM tech is going to have its own problems. For example, if it has to sit close to a vein, and you move it slightly. Or if it has to be relatively tight on the wrist. Or if the LED's get dirty because of sweat.
- Osmium 12y agoThanks for the feedback--that's interesting. I'd assumed these were all LED based. If it is electrical contact related, could you not use a gel like another commenter mentioned using with a chest strap? It seems like a gimmick, but I've had good results with one of the iPhone apps where you place your finger over the camera and it's illuminated by the flash. You have to keep the finger in a constant position, but it works reliably if you do. So I have hope for new technology. Completely different area, but there's this technology: http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/vidmag/ http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/vidmag/ which seems surprisingly robust. If you can get heart rate from standard video, I wouldn't be surprised to find it's possible to get a reliable signal with a LED and light sensor placed directly against the skin–especially if it's done in addition to an electrical signal. Either way, we'll find out soon enough. The Apple watch claims to give heart rate too, and they're going to get absolutely slammed in the media if they don't live up to it. Will be interesting to see!