4 ms·
Could someone please give me a quick explanation on how voting works in the US? Do you just turn up and vote? Where I live you need to bring your national ID wi
by gambiting 12y ago
Could someone please give me a quick explanation on how voting works in the US? Do you just turn up and vote? Where I live you need to bring your national ID with you(it looks like a driving licence), staff at the voting office checks the number to see if you haven't voted already, and then you are given a sheet to put your vote on. How could non-citizens even register to vote in the US?
- lsh123 12y agoIt varies state by state but in general you first register to vote by submitting a snail mail or an online application; and then just show up at the voting place, find yourself in a long list of names, and vote. Personally, I never had to show any kind of ID during the process.
- x1798DE 12y agoIn Texas they just added a voter ID law, and my experience was essentially the same as it used to be in Massachusetts - show up, you're on a long list of names, etc, but now you have to show a government-issued ID to vote. I'm not sure how it works if you vote by mail or do early voting.
- VLM 12y agoAs a public service I will make a fast post that it is completely state controlled. Not federal level. Where I live we dump all state drivers license and state ID card records into a pool and thats about 99% of the population right there. Volunteer octogenarians at the public elementary school your kids would attend, ask you your address and then name and then tag you in the records as having voted, then hand out "scantron" ballots and pencils which are optically scanned and reported to central control hourly or so and the ballots are later spot checked. Every task takes at least two octogenarians, we have a one party system in the USA with two competing P.R. firms and each firm provides one overseer for each job. Never in my life have I had to provide ID to vote. There is a policy no one really knows to handle people who recently move or refuse to obtain a free ID card or a relatively cheap drivers license. Note that we give out "free" state ID cards upon demand, but obtaining the prerequisite certified birth certificate is no picnic and costs something like $95, if you don't already have one. Identity theft is quite trivial but the punishment is somewhat severe once you're caught.
- cafard 12y agoI have voted voted most recently in the District of Columbia. There you do provide a photo ID, in my case my driver's license. At this point I don't remember whether or not I had to provide photo ID in Maryland: that was year's ago. Nor do I remember how I registered to vote here, but I think it probably was at the Department of Motor Vehicles when I got my DC driver's license. In Maryland, I think that I mailed in a form one time; in Colorado, long ago, I drove to the county courthouse and registered with the county clerk.
- djur 12y agoI'm going to answer a question implied by your question first. There is no single effective record of citizenship in the United States, nor is there any kind of national ID program. Social Security numbers are frequently used as proof of identity but it is possible not to have one. They are not proof of citizenship. To give you an idea of what this looks like, to get an official photo ID from the State of Oregon you need to provide proof of state residency (generally this takes the form of a utility bill, bank correspondence, etc. with your name and an in-state address on it), identity (a social security card, another state ID, a passport), and legal presence in the US -- which either means legal residency or citizenship. In the case of naturalized citizens, this is simple: you're issued paperwork when you gain citizenship. Proof of natural citizenship is more complicated[1], because there's a lot of ways to be born a US citizen, some of which don't automatically result in documents being filed. People who drive will get a state driver's license, which generally has the same requirements in addition to a driving test and the like. State ID cards are frequently just driver's licenses with an indication added that they aren't actually a license to drive! That all leads to the actual answer to your question: every state handles voting differently. Some require you to register in advance, others don't; some require photo ID, others don't. My state and a few others conduct voting by mail. Eligibility standards are also allowed to vary by state, with a few constitutional limitations introduced by amendment. That's a whole topic in itself, but the brief summary is that there is no constitutionally defined positive right to vote in the US, only a set of criteria that states are not allowed to use to exclude voters (age if older than 18, sex, race). Any major reform of this system would require a constitutional amendment, which is a very high bar to jump in the US. [1]: http://www.oregon.gov/ODOT/DMV/pages/driverid/idproof.aspx#legal_presence http://www.oregon.gov/ODOT/DMV/pages/driverid/idproof.aspx#l...
- gambiting 12y agoThank you very much for the throughout explanation. I always assumed there was an easy way to determine if someone is a citizen or not, but clearly that's not the case. It does make the whole voting issue a lot more complicated, had no idea it was as such.
- JoeAltmaier 12y ago