4 ms·
Neat webapp, quite impressive. Still, I’m disappointed at how lazy the UI design of nearly all image editors is. They take off-the-shelf algorithms/models, imp
by jacobolus 12y ago
Neat webapp, quite impressive.
Still, I’m disappointed at how lazy the UI design of nearly all image editors is. They take off-the-shelf algorithms/models, implement them in code, and then slap a slider widget in for every parameter in the model. A big wall of sliders takes basically zero thought or effort from a UI design perspective, which is why it’s so popular, but other than being ubiquitous, it’s generally a mediocre UI in comparison to something that has had real thought put into it.
(But again, that’s nothing unique to this app. Adobe Lightroom takes the same lazy way out. Several of the tools that have been in Photoshop since before 1995 are a bit more powerful/flexible, but everything they’ve added in the past 20 years seems to follow the wall-of-sliders model. Some expensive professional video color grading applications are a bit better, but still nothing too special.)
- bwang29 12y agoI reckon with the the lack of UI innovation. On tablets and photos there are quite some newer designs in terms of adjusting the knobs and values while leveraging gestures. Waterfall design is a lazy starting point. The innovation in this app is making a usable WebGL editor that handles multiple editing sessions without suffering serious memory issues and crashes.
- greyskull 12y agoDo you have suggestions? When I look at applications oriented towards prosumers and professionals like this, photoshop, etc. I think the point is to give complete control to the user. I don't know anything about photo editing.
- PavlovsCat 12y agoOne can always take inspiration from audio software and audio plugins, some of those have quite slick UI ideas.
- beering 12y agoOh please, no. The fact that every VST maker creates their own custom GUI from scratch was the best and worst thing to happen to VSTs. All of a sudden I have a gazillion different plugins each with their own idea of how user interaction should work, meaning I learn a new interface for every single plugin. At least a wall of homogenous sliders doesn't require me to learn how the widgets work.
- PavlovsCat 12y agoSure, but one doesn't have to reinvent the slider every time to do more than just "list them". Grouping elements, maybe even color coding groups, graphical indicators along with numerical values, all those things go a long way, and don't preclude standardization of the input elements themselves. Maybe they'd need to be more customizable. > At least a wall of homogenous sliders doesn't require me to learn how the widgets work. That wall is available in many if not all VST hosts, you can still work with the raw parameter list; and I have to say, I for one do not prefer it, at least not for any plugin that has more than 5-10 things to tweak. Except when I know them by name and can filter the list with a few keystrokes, so for that and other reasons I think a normalized is also useful. It doesn't have to be one or the other.
- xanderstrike 12y agoPhotographer here. We know what these functions are doing to the image (if not literally then intuitively) and want the total control that the sliders-next-to-input-fields paradigm provides. You might be surprised how much math actually goes into photography. Yes I do want to bump the contrast by .1 and drop the exposure by 1/3 of a stop. I've got my eye on the histogram and I know what I think looks good. I guarantee that any photo editing software that deviates from this UI will get shat on by the professional photography community. I'd love to see your suggestions nonetheless. The type of interface that I think you're suggesting is Instagram, one that takes control away from the user because the user doesn't actually know what they're doing. This editor actually has something like that with the filters you can select on the left. The problem is, actual photographers are frustrated by these interfaces (or treat them as a toy) because they would rather have all the functionality exposed to them so they can make their own adjustments. You could argue that "constraints breed creativity," but when I'm working through 1500 wedding photos I want my sliders exactly where I expect them to be, doing exactly what they've been doing with high precision for the past 20 years.