4 ms·
> I remember back 10 years ago, the Internet was actually useful. You could search for a product review and not get a bunch of computer-generated crap SEO opti
by chaostheory 12y ago
> I remember back 10 years ago, the Internet was actually useful. You could search for a product review and not get a bunch of computer-generated crap SEO optimized to turn up at the top.
It's still pretty useful. I just use Amazon for reviews instead of Google now. ;)
- rayiner 12y agoUser generated reviews are among the most useless things on the Internet. The SNR is unspeakably awful. I don't pay any attention to ratings on Amazon, etc. I wait for a detailed review by Ars, Anand, Tom, etc, or the equivalent for products in another field.
- chaostheory 12y agoHow is it useless? Yes there are a lot of crappy one or two sentence reviews, but there are plenty of useful ones as well. Consumer Reports doesn't have the resources to review everything and neither do outlets like CNET.
- rayiner 12y agoUser reviews are highly skewed towards those with extreme experiences and often based on undisclosed idiosyncrasies. Users post a bad review after one negative experience, and there are many Amazon reviews where it doesn't even appear to be the case that the person has actually used the product. Creating a valuable review actually requires a systematic approach. Take, for example, a review of a cell phone's battery life. Such reviews are useless without disclosure of your usage patterns, whether you're in a good signal or bad signal area, whether you like to jack up the brightness to 100%, etc. And aggregating a bunch of shoddy reviews can't compare to one good one.
- chaostheory 12y ago> User reviews are highly skewed towards those with extreme experiences and often based on undisclosed idiosyncrasies. Users post a bad review after one negative experience, and there are many Amazon reviews where it doesn't even appear to be the case that the person has actually used the product. Typically the greater the number of consumer reviews will offset this problem. Again, some information is better than no information. > And aggregating a bunch of shoddy reviews can't compare to one good one. As you've already mentioned, many people can discern bad reviews from good ones. It's not perfect but it's better than nothing.
- rayiner 12y agoE.g. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=9SIA24G1FB3694 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=9SIA24G1FB36.... 3 of the 5 reviews of this Dell 4K monitor are clearly using it on computers that can't drive 4k@60 HZ. The fourth is from someone who owns a completely different, non-4K Dell monitor. That leaves one reliable review, which provides very little information. I wish I could say I were cherry-picking.
- chaostheory 12y agoThe best consumer reviews are typically found on Amazon. Moreover, you're still ignoring the problem of established organizations being unable to review the massive amounts of incoming products that are produced and shipped every year.
- cloakandswagger 12y ago>User generated reviews are among the most useless things on the Internet. Ranking up there with your hyperbolic comment.