4 ms·
We are in the early days of online harassment being taken as a serious problem
- dang 12y agoSince the article's headline doesn't reflect its contents (and would likely lead to definitional debates), we changed it to a sentence from the article that does.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoFacebook now requires admins of groups deemed to be using hateful or offensive speech to publicly identify themselves. Anyone familiar with the history of Usenet will know that real name policies aren't an effective approach.
- arbitrage 12y agoConsidering that there was no real name verification built into USENET at all, and no central authority, this is not an apt analogy.
- emotionalcode 12y agoThreatening reprecussion also doesn't stop prejudice, discrimination, or harassment - it just makes it happen behind closed doors or within closed minds. It's the cultural shift of ethics and values that changes things. That's something people have to learn for themselves though, through the experience of changing, and the only person that can judge whether that change results in positives, benefits or gains, (or just something outside of what they currently experience) for the individual is the individual themselves.
- mindslight 12y agoThe proposed solution: "societal pressure". That certainly seems innocuous enough. But online harassers are a tiny group already-marginalized people (asserting otherwise is willfully ignoring obvious numbers, and that should make anybody wary). Increasing the scorn is not going to change them! When this approach inevitably fails, then this same "societal pressure" will be parlayed into the newly-created common wisdom of outright censorship of the Internet.
- talmand 12y agoI would agree increasing the scorn is likely to have the opposite effect. It would seem these type of people feed off such things. Increasing the level of response, even if it is negative, will only further one of the goals of the harassers; getting the attention of people while they commit the harassment. Anonymous-based movements on the Internet are just the feeding trough for these type of people, regardless of the alleged motives of the movement.
- chillingeffect 12y agoThe article likens societal pressure to sexual harassment in the workplace. However, the power structure is not the same. In the workplace, bosses/admins had to be convinced to treat the problem different, then the wielded the power to make people cooperate. Online harassment doesn't feature an authority figure who can cutoff the access of the harassers though. What is the solution? I don't know. I think the death threats are a result of the self-hatred and sense of disposession our consumer society creates. We are motivated by the fear of not having enough and therefore our primal minds are constantly threatened. The people at the bottom have little to lose and act out.
- tedks 12y ago>When this approach inevitably fails, then this same "societal pressure" will be parlayed into the new common wisdom of outright censorship of the Internet. I don't think it's possible to say that social pressure, or in other words, education, is definitely going to fail. Harassers are people. We need to teach boys that they are not, in fact, entitled to women's bodies, and hopefully then not just online harassment but also street harassment, sexual harassment, and sexual assault will decrease. But what's wrong with blocking 4chan, or gamergaters.com or whatever else? These are sites that are demonstratably, reliably causing people gross personal distress and sometimes egging people on into massive acts of violence. Notably, the UC Santa Barbara shooter was a 4chan member, and almost certainly was radicalized there. It's easy to say that "free speech" or "censorship-free internet" are good things; it's much harder to look at the actual statistics and realize that every post on 4chan is a little piece of an inevitable hate crime. The average is the total over the number; regardless of the small average contribution of each 4chan post to harassment and violence, the end result is GamerGate and mass murder. Ironically, when it comes to Muslims doing the same thing as white men on 4chan, the media and hacker news is united in wanting to shut down "radical Islamist forums." At the end of the day, you have to decide what's more important: an internet where no website is blocked, or the safety of women. If you decide the former, you are every bit as responsible for the deaths of women as the people who physically pull the trigger, because you said nothing and did nothing when you could have stopped the root cause. As another point, there is massive value to the survivors in making it absolutely clear that what happened to them is not okay; that they did not deserve it; that they should be outraged and that the perpetrators, when caught, will be punished and ostracized. The only way to do this is by actually condemning, punishing, and ostracizing perpetrators. The benefits of solidarity are very real; women who experience victim-blaming after sexual assault have vastly higher rates of PTSD. So societal pressure in favor of feminism and away from male entitlement seems like a fine way to address this problem, and if it leads to the death of websites that organize harassment campaigns so much the better.
- penprog 12y ago>The bundle of nightmares that is the GamerGate movement, an amorphous collection of gamers largely focused on harassing feminist game developers and critics, managed to make the front page of The New York Times. Why did I know this article had to do with #gamergate, can we get this shit out of here? This is a highly politicized and uninteresting topic.
- delecti 12y agoGamerGate is merely a symptom of a society that allows online harassment (or at least doesn't sufficiently persecute it), and it's currently a very visible example. Of course there are assholes in the movement, there are in any side of any movement. The problem is that they've got access to weapons which are largely unregulated.
- penprog 12y agoI don't care about GamerGate, what I care about is that every single media outlet is spamming this topic and it would die a lot faster if they ignored it. I can go to any other website for social commentary, do we want Hacker News to be a battleground for social justice or do we want it to be a place where we can actually discuss something interesting. Almost every other discussion website had the good sense to ban this topic because it only leads to flame wars and name calling.
- talmand 12y agoJust curious, which "weapons" do you think require regulations?
- jerf 12y agoOur psyches are tuned for a world where a village of several hundred people is pretty big. No matter how rational you may think you are, when stepping into a "village" of millions just getting normal, non-harassing feedback that happens to be partially negative can be overwhelming to your emotions, even before we discuss people systematically abusing negative feedback. The worst thing about the "weapons" is that they aren't even "weapons"... they're just... communication. How can we fix harassment when just plain normal usage of the relevant channels alone can be emotionally overwhelming? Serious question for serious thought. I've got no practical answer and I've been pondering this question off and on for at least 15 years now.
- spindritf 12y agoThis is part of a larger attack on anonymity online. That piece from Pacific Standard mentioned in the OP certainly was[1]. Before, it was "think of the children" used by politicians to justify various censorship measures[2]. Now, it's "think of women" used by the media to undermine anonymous communication. They cannot profit from it therefore anyone who doesn't post banalities under their real name, so they can be safely adorned with ads, is a troll and an abuser. [1] http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/05/cyberbll.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/05/cyberbll.html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children#As_justification_for_censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children#As_justi...
- zzalpha 12y agoOr, you know, alternatively, maybe online harassment is actually a problem. But you're right, a massive government/capitalist co-conspiracy working to end your right to anonymity is definitely the more reasonable explanation...
- Yourfags 12y agoHow much does it really effect you? Is anyone besides you even going to notice it? I'm just not really aware of where this is an issue, isn't a ban/block/ignore significant enough to stop just about any attack? If someone's getting around those, they're spending a considerable amount of effort... *edit - more to the point
- chillingeffect 12y agoHow come it is only being considered a serious problem now? When it was just men getting harassed, wasn't it serious then too?