4 ms·
That still leaves the possibility that Bitcoin's rules (semi-fixed block reward and 21M BTC limit) are bad and some other altcoin will have much better rules.
by wmf 12y ago
That still leaves the possibility that Bitcoin's rules (semi-fixed block reward and 21M BTC limit) are bad and some other altcoin will have much better rules.
- kristofferR 12y agoWell, that's honestly irrelevant as long as Bitcoin is the only cryptocurrency with any significant market share. Bitcoin's market share is currently over 15 times larger than the combined market share of the following 10 most popular cryptocurrencies! An altcoin could be much better than Bitcoin technically or economically/philosophically, but it wouldn't matter since Bitcoin would be much better in practical use due to its market penetration. An altcoin could do some really cool stuff that would in theory make it more secure than Bitcoin, but Bitcoin would be vastly more secure in practice due to its massive network. And if an objective flaw actually were discovered in Bitcoin, it would be solved pretty quickly.
- ericb 12y agoI don't believe this outcome is possible for anything related to a rules change. Maybe for better functionality, but I have my doubts about that too. In terms of the rules, it would mean we collectively have learned to solve something like the tragedy of the commons problem or a collective prisoners dilemma. Market participants would have to en-mass choose an asset which is worse for each of them as individuals (as it loses value) for the sake of the greater good. Without a government forcing the issue, it is my belief this can't happen.
- DennisP 12y agoTrue, but a lot of people have tried building altcoins with modified rules, and so far none have come close to dethroning Bitcoin. On the other hand, substantially better technology that Bitcoin can't easily adopt might be another matter. Ethereum and Zerocash are a couple interesting candidates.