2 ms·
> It's not valid to argue from ignorance that something that hasn't been tried cannot possibly work. Again, it's not deductively logically valid, but it is mos
by gwern 12y ago
> It's not valid to argue from ignorance that something that hasn't been tried cannot possibly work.
Again, it's not deductively logically valid, but it is most certainly inductively and statistically valid, and those are the validities that concern us: absence of evidence is evidence of absence, and for few things is there a more glaring absence than for intelligence boosts. After a century of formal pursuit, what do we have to show for it? A few very early childhood interventions like iodine; some interventions one should trust as far as one can kick them like dual n-back; and some stimulants offering temporary boosts (but are they boosting actual peak intelligence or just affecting motivation?).
- barry-cotter 12y agoWhy are you still operating on the principle of charity with tokenadult? He has refused to engage with a stable of similar arguments for years, from. He varies between arguing like he was trained for getting his J.D. (arguments as soldiers, argument from authority, argumentum ad hominem) and arguing as he would have during his math degree, by exclusion and contradiction, as convenient for his ideology. He's obviously well acquainted with the literature, witness his perennial work sample test bit but he places radically different burdens of proof on ideologically convenient and inconvenient arguments.