4 ms·
> But he also writes, in a later commentary article, "Heritability isn't an index of how genetic a trait is. A great deal of time has been wasted in the effort
by gwern 12y ago
> But he also writes, in a later commentary article, "Heritability isn't an index of how genetic a trait is. A great deal of time has been wasted in the effort of measuring the heritability of traits in the false expectation that somehow the genetic nature of psychological phenomena would be revealed. There are many reasons for making this strong statement, but the most important of them harkens back to the description of heritability as an effect size."[2]
It is true that heritability does not logically imply immalleabillity. But, leaving aside the many cases of untreatable or fatal genetic diseases as possibly too easy, I am struck by how often heritability does turn out to be about traits which are difficult or impossible to change; we are familiar with the case of intelligence, of course, but it shows up almost anywhere heritability does. Consider the case of politics: political affiliation is highly stable over lifetimes, impenetrable to argumentation, people will tie themselves in knots to preserve their beliefs (consider the people who argue that WMDs were successfully found in Iraq), increasingly linked to fundamental differences in cognition (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8512400 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8512400 ) - and political attitudes are highly heritable (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8512399 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8512399 / https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8504593 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8504593). This pattern pops up over and over again: if a study calculates the heritability of a number of traits, the traits which are high on heritability and low on shared environment will strike one as things which are hard to change. If you don't like attitudes or politics or intelligence, consider personality like the Big Five construct: OCEAN are all highly heritable (~40% avg), and yet, largely unchangeable. Do you know any way to increase Conscientiousness aside from dopaminergic stimulants? I don't. Do you know any way to increase Openness besides possibly psychedelics? I don't. And so on.
> Associations of candidate genes with psychological traits and other traits studied in the social sciences should be viewed as tentative until they have been replicated in multiple large samples. Doing otherwise may hamper scientific progress by proliferating potentially false results, which may then influence the research agendas of scientists who do not appreciate that the associations they take as a starting point for their efforts may not be real. And the dissemination of false results to the public risks creating an incorrect perception about the state of knowledge in the field, especially the existence of genes described as being 'for' traits on the basis of unintentionally inflated estimates of effect size and statistical significance."[3]
It would be nice if, in your constant citation of Chabris, you would incorporate any of the information I've given you in my other replies to you.
- tokenadult 12y agoAs Alan S. Kaufman wrote in each edition of his textbook Assessing Adolescent and Adult Intelligence (I read the first edition in the early 1990s), what you and I don't know about effective environmental interventions to raise IQ does not at all imply that none existence. It's not valid to argue from ignorance that something that hasn't been tried cannot possibly work. Kaufman took care in the first edition of his textbook to point out that we were by no means sure in that era what was causing the Flynn effect (we still aren't completely sure about that). But he also noted that it is logically quite possible that we will discover environmental influences to boost IQ (or, more importantly, boost actual human achievement outside the testing room) that are well within our control as we engage in further research.
- Rylinks 12y agoWe have, right now, short-term environmental influences that boost IQ, for example, nicotine.
- barry-cotter 12y agoDoes nicotine boost IQ in the same way as Vyvanse, Adderall or speed? Because they don't raise IQ, they raise performance by increasing focus, which is approximately increasing conscientiousness. The effects on measured IQ are nugatory. Being able to work harder, for longer is not being smarter. If you have access to some research to the contrary please share.
- barry-cotter 12y ago>As Alan S. Kaufman wrote in each edition of his textbook Assessing Adolescent and Adult Intelligence (I read the first edition in the early 1990s), what you and I don't know about effective environmental interventions to raise IQ does not at all imply that none existence. It's not valid to argue from ignorance that something that hasn't been tried cannot possibly work. The Blank Slate, everyone has equal potential view has been the underlying education school dogma since at least the early seventies. People have been searching for ways to raise and equalise outcomes for (I think) longer than you have been alive. No one has found anything that does both. Absence of evidence is in fact evidence of absence, and the more effort, time and money has been expended in the search for evidence the stronger the evidence for absence is.