2 ms·
The semantic web as originally proposed (Berners-Lee, Hendler, Lassila) is as dead as last year's roadkill, though there are plenty out there that pretend that'
by mindcrime 12y ago
The semantic web as originally proposed (Berners-Lee, Hendler, Lassila) is as dead as last year's roadkill, though there are plenty out there that pretend that's not the case. There's still plenty of groups trying to revive the original idea, or like most things in the KM field, they've simply changed the definition to encompass something else that looks like it might work instead.
I think it's equally disingenuous to suggest that a vision, and associated definitions, aren't allowed to evolve - and to suggest that "X failed" because "X" isn't exactly the same today as it was in 1999.
One of the reasons that whole thing died was that existing business models simply couldn't be reworked to make it make sense. If I'm running an ad driven site about Cat Breeds, simply giving you all my information in an easy to parse machine readable form so your site on General Pet Breeds can exist and make money is not something I'm particularly inclined to do
It may not make sense for every use-case, but plenty of companies have found value in using SemWeb technologies.
http://readwrite.com/2010/06/30/how_best_buy_is_using_the_semantic_web http://readwrite.com/2010/06/30/how_best_buy_is_using_the_se...
- bane 12y ago> I think it's equally disingenuous to suggest that a vision, and associated definitions, aren't allowed to evolve - and to suggest that "X failed" because "X" isn't exactly the same today as it was in 1999. I think that's absolutely a fair criticism of my critique. However, I stand by my critique. Nobody is still calling cars "horseless carriages". At some point, things stop evolving and become something else. The SW has had 13 years to demonstrate value and really hasn't been able to do it in any broad sense while everything else the SW was promising has been met and exceeded by non-SW approaches (which are now being co-opted and called the "Semantic Web" simply because they work). I think my main thrust is that the Semantic Web failed. That's okay. We learned a lot. Now it's time for something else to take over, call it "Cross Domain Reasoning Systems" or "Global Presence" or some other Gartner Conference ready term. The Dinosaurs died, and that's too bad, but we learned a lot, and out of that we ended up with birds, of which Chickens and Turkeys are delicious. But it's time to put it to bed and move on. I've found it always curious that people who work with Semantics have such a bad understanding of what things actually mean.