5 ms·
I like the idea. But... Is faster typing really the solution to the problem of wanting to professionalize computer programming? And is that even a problem? I
by analog31 12y ago
I like the idea. But...
Is faster typing really the solution to the problem of wanting to professionalize computer programming? And is that even a problem?
I play the double bass. The problem that faster "entry" solves for musical instruments is wanting to express complex ideas in real time.
- darkmighty 12y agoExactly. Upgrading the keyboard in this case is more like improving your composing sheet or getting a better pen for composing -- not the limiting factor at all. I guess the real 'instrument upgrade' analogy in this case would be upgrading the human mind, or perhaps a well tuned programming language.
- ObviousScience 12y agoTyping has never been the road block. It's the inability to blend typing with other kinds of media I generate - easy references to diagrams, notes, reference papers, etc - that is my limiting factor, that is stopping my work for moving closer to my ideal of what a professional solution in software should look like. I want some web-esque way to blend the several kinds of artifacts I make as a programmer in an easy to generate manner from a system that understands I'll be generating all these kinds of things, and that they're all fundamentally different expressions of the same idea. That way I can blend drawing and doodling doing what they're they're good at with text entry with what it's good at, and create the deeper and more meaningful references that underscore the idea (or composition of ideas) I'm attempting, and not have several stand-alone pieces that don't express their relationships and interdependencies correctly. Telling me how to play the violin faster doesn't help me conduct a symphony of ideas, and shows that the people proffering answers don't even understand what my problem actually is. (Hint: I'm rarely the one playing any particular instrument; rather, I'm trying to explain how I'll bring all the instruments to bear together on a single piece.)
- agumonkey 12y agoI even think that slow input systems have benefits. I remember feeling awkward when using an HP48 (GUI was sluggish compared to other simpler calc) but it was so consistent, you didn't really care about it, you could think in advance, fill the buffer and think while the computer was processing the input. In the end, you'd enjoyed the slowness. It was a non-thing. Also, back when people had to book computer time 1h per week, they had to think the thing through before asking the compiler to check and run the code. I'm pretty sure they didn't want to waste their time slot on a misplaced comma.
- dropit_sphere 12y ago>Is faster typing really the solution to the problem of wanting to professionalize computer programming? And is that even a problem? Perhaps not for desktop programming. But why am I only allowed to do meaningful work in an upright posture at a desk? One-handed development on a train would be pretty awesome.
- pmoriarty 12y agoI'd like to find a one-handed keyboard that I can use in my pocket, without having to look at it, and which I can use with a relaxed, comfortably closed fist. Pressing the buttons on it should require only the lightest touch. Unfortunately, I haven't seen anything remotely close to this.
- pnathan 12y agoI think that that's not the point here. The point is that software is often designed towards the average or median home user (i.e., mobile), not designed towards the professional software developer or the professional & expert users. Or, we conflate power with needing to be confusing(git, bash). Probably the only piece of software I've heavily used that I can comfortably say is designed for professionals is emacs, and it's got well-known issues early on the learning curve. Arguably 30 years of modification in a system designed for modification have moved us to that happy place.
- femto 12y agoI think software is often designed towards the average or median programmer, not user. Professional software has to be written so one's successors can work with it, so it is typically written with a typical successor (ie. average or median) in mind. If this isn't the case, the typical management (ie. average or median) judge the predecessor to have been incompetent, as no one can understand his work, so it must be junk. For example, I'd love to be more productive and use a WYSISYM system for my documentation, but the median person in the company that I work for can't get their head past a bog standard word processor, so won't be able to further develop what I write. Some companies work on a higher plane, but most companies contain median programmers with median management, and need everyone to work at that level.
- pnathan 12y ago"most companies contain median programmers with median management" I refer to that as the law of large numbers for work. Everything regresses to the mean. As someone who strives regularly to push beyond the mean, it's extremely frustrating.
- EdiX 12y ago>Is faster typing really the solution to the problem of wanting to professionalize computer programming? I think both you and the article are making a mistake here. If you listen closely to the 1968 demo and, especially, its 1969 follow-up (available on archive.org) it's clear that Engelbart was not using the chorded keyboard for text input but for command input. You should think of NLS text editor as a vi without cursor addressing: you would enter the command to execute with the chorded keyboard then select the target character/word/sentence with the mouse cursor. You can follow the evolution of this idea throughout history. Many of Engelbart's "employees" went to work for Xerox Labs, the Xerox Alto used the keyset to give commands just like Engelbart's NLS. The keyset was removed from Xerox Star after it proved to hard to learn and replaced with an extra block of keys on the left of the keyboard [2] with the most used commands. When apple copied from xerox they got rid of this extra block (probably in the name of ease of use) but someone kept the idea alive by inventing the ctrl-zxcv for undo, cut, copy, paste that are conveniently placed all on the left side of the keyboard, so that you can use them while your other hand is on the mouse, like Engelbart always intended. On this page [1] you can see some of the command given using a combination of the keyset (the chorded keyboard) and the mouse, it is not exhaustive however. [1] http://chm.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?NlsTechnical/KeysetMap http://chm.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?NlsTechnical/KeysetMap [2] http://www.digibarn.com/friends/curbow/star/keyboard/keyboard2.JPG http://www.digibarn.com/friends/curbow/star/keyboard/keyboar...
- DennisP 12y agoVim even has the verb-noun structure that Engelbart advocated. A while back I played around with some old Windows 3.0 software based on Engelbart's Augment. The modern tool closest in spirit to it is probably Emacs org-mode with evil-mode.
- leoc 12y ago> Engelbart was not using the chorded keyboard for text input but for command input. It was designed for both, and certainly Engelbart himself could and did type with it. Context menus (originally from Smalltalk) are another substitute for the expanded command set of NLS' chording-augmented mouse. The advantage of having a chord keyboard for typing is that you can avoid the mouse-to-keyboard-to-mouse hand-movements that are so annoying when you can only type with a two-handed keyboard. However a one-handed chord keyboard is even slower than two-handed QWERTY when it comes to typing, all else being equal, and there is obviously the burden of having to learn it. For programmers and many other people, then, a better setup is probably a two-hand keyboard that lets you control a mouse pointer with minimal hand movement: and in fact we now have these, in the form of pointing-stick keyboards and keyboards with a trackpad in relatively easy reach of the user's thumbs http://www.loper-os.org/?p=861&cpage=1#comment-16138 http://www.loper-os.org/?p=861&cpage=1#comment-16138 . The mystery is why why people are still selling and buying expensive keyboards without either.