2 ms·
One could argue that Marx himself felt he was witnessing the apocalypse, and yet here we are. My biggest issue with this particular take on it is this, "The co
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
One could argue that Marx himself felt he was witnessing the apocalypse, and yet here we are.
My biggest issue with this particular take on it is this, "The consumer vision that is pushed by advertising and which is conquering the world is based fundamentally, as I argued before, on a notion of economic growth."
Advertising is not based on growth, it is based on consumption. There is a difference. Let me see if this analogy helps; Survival requires spending money, there is only so much money in the world, once we run out society as we know it will collapse. The fallacy there is two fold, it presupposes that once spent money is destroyed, and secondly that without money society could not operate.
People are, for lack of a better term, actors in a large interconnected system, they both charge the system with work and drain the system with consumption. The 'value' of this system, its GDP, sloshes around from place to place, concentrating at times and dispersing at times. Without its motion, the system stops. Advertising is a means by which actors in the system attempt to get a bit of GDP to slosh their way. They spend some to get some as it were. Sometimes the actors follow along, sometimes they don't. I feel that the effect of advertising on the sloshing around of GDP is a second order effect at best.
Back when my kids were younger the topic of the richest person in the whole world came up. And the obvious kid question, "What would happen if one person got all of the money in the world?" and the answer is we'd switch to barter, instead of buying groceries with dollars we might buy them with traded services. GDP or "production" isn't money, it is something more fundamental than that. Money is merely a convenient accounting system which works well enough for many cultures.