3 ms·
Joe Schmo losing his $20k/yr burger flipping job for a year will suffer far more than Bill Gates losing $20B in a market fluctuation, despite the fact that the
by jjoonathan 12y ago
Joe Schmo losing his $20k/yr burger flipping job for a year will suffer far more than Bill Gates losing $20B in a market fluctuation, despite the fact that the latter is literally 1,000,000 times worse on paper. Monetary risk and utility risk are not the same thing and choosing one over the other is equivalent to picking a side in the debate.
As for optimizing opportunity between labor and capital, I tend to suspect that this metric would favor more equitable wealth distribution so as to maximize the feasibility of bootstrapping (low overhead, perverse incentives avoided, nothing remotely exploitative about it on either end of the deal) and to maximize the "surface contact" between capital and labor. But nobody is looking to maximize opportunity in general, only their individual opportunity, and the Nash equilibrium for that process lies in exactly the same place as the Nash equilibrium for wealth.
- dkfmn 12y agoOf course there's a difference between monetary risk and utility risk. They shouldn't be conflated in this discussion for a number of reasons. One such is that measuring utility is very difficult without resorting to a yardstick like capital. You also bring up personal utility which is important. How do you balance the risk of a destroyed livelihood against a much greater capital loss? We also have to be careful not to presume that Joe Schmo can't find another job (better or equivalent).