3 ms·
It does seem that traditionally, weapons are at the forefront technological development. So Musk might have a point. That being said, I see bio-engineering as
by jqm 12y ago
It does seem that traditionally, weapons are at the forefront technological development. So Musk might have a point.
That being said, I see bio-engineering as much more likely and immediately possible route to human extinction. But I suppose we could also have artificial intelligence guiding bio-engineering which might speed the process up....
Most likely, the eventual extinction of the current human species is inevitable. It has happened plenty of times before. There were other hominid species before and during the time Homo Sapiens appeared, we still carry some of their genes but they are extinct. Why would we suppose our particular species will be any different? Life is succession of organisms. And it doesn't seem the function of life is to preserve species, but rather to preserve and enhance genes.
Oh I know... Being human, I'm not crazy about the idea either. But I can't help seeing our position within the larger framework. I can't believe we are at the pinnacle of what life can become, nor do I believe the process of evolution will forever freeze with the appearance of this strange kind of ape.
Maybe the next iteration of apes will spend more time doing things other than looking under trees for nuts to hide in their nests and sharpening sticks to poke other monkeys..... Because it seems these are some of the primary occupations of the variety to which I belong. Then again, maybe they will do exactly this, but much better. Probably. Ah well... life. If you can't beat it, join it. Now were did I leave my stick at?
- firebrand39 12y agoSo it is much more a problem of AI getting into the wrong hands than AI itself. Which raises the prospect that it may get used prematurely and with weaknesses. This reduces very much the self perfection scenario completely without human intervention. In turn, the human/AI evil scenario warrants a look at the history of "empire builders". ... long story .... But I do believe that history is not Musk's forte. And btw, what about crowd sourcing and scaling? Just bog standard human collaboration. I would not underestimate this (history again). These things can be just as powerful as AI.
- firebrand39 12y agoActually, the more I think about it, the more I think Mr. Musk is baiting us.
- cfreeman 12y agoI feel like he is too. There is just something so vague about his AI pronouncements.