11 ms·
The Scientific 7-Minute Workout
- conception 12y agoPlease note you are supposed to do the 7 minute workout 2-3 times.
- danso 12y agoReally? The original piece (which apparently was popular enough to get the NYT devs to make an app) pushed the premise that 7 minutes could produce "molecular changes within muscles comparable to those of several hours of running or bike riding" http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/09/the-scientific-7-minute-workout/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/09/the-scientific-7-mi... > The exercises should be performed in rapid succession, allowing 30 seconds for each, while, throughout, the intensity hovers at about an 8 on a discomfort scale of 1 to 10, Mr. Jordan says. Those seven minutes should be, in a word, unpleasant. The upside is, after seven minutes, you’re done. The article was updated today (which is where I saw the app link) (http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/10/24/the-advanced-7-minute-workout/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/10/24/the-advanced-7-minu...)...it talks about how the 7-minute workout is "not meant to be your sole exercise"...but that's out of concern that it "will become monotonous and demotivating"
- tootie 12y agoThe original study said the 7 minute routine should be repeated 2 to 3 times. It also listed a sample regimen which most people took too literally. You're supposed to vary the exercises and there are dozens of options. Johnson and Johnson have a really good app with lots of options.
- encoderer 12y agoYes, this is correct. The study itself -- if not the NYT coverage of it -- mentions the workout is designed for people with sedentary lives and it should be repeated 2-3 times to see results in people in better physical condition.
- avalaunch 12y agoPeople keep mentioning that the study says that the workout should be repeated 2-3 times but what it actually says is that the "Participants can repeat the 7-minute bout 2 to 3 times, depending on the amount of time they have." To me that implies that repeating 2-3 times is optional, and that once is enough to see results. Also, as an aside, if you are repeating something 2-3 times, doesn't that mean you're doing it a total of 3-4 times?
- maerF0x0 12y agoA neat website, but where are the links to the "Science" ?
- gilgoomesh 12y agoMy thoughts exactly. There is zero science here.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Iftheshoefits 12y ago"Sorry, Well Workouts requires iOS 7 or greater, the Android Chrome browser, or Internet Explorer 11." So Android Firefox users aren't supposed to view their website?
- TrainedMonkey 12y agoScience is that if you work out all major groups of muscles with maximum intensity you use up all of the stored ATP energy and trigger anaerobic energy delivery mechanism which builds up lactic acid [0]. Do this for all major muscle groups and you get significantly raised metabolism throughout the day as your body deals with replenishing ATP, cleaning up lactic acid, and repairing small amount muscle micro tears. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_systems
- l33tbro 12y agoI'm building a site like this at the moment and things like this made me happy we chose video and real humans - instead of vector images. Showing people how to exercise in 7 minutes is easy - but motivating them to exercise is a totally different thing. I get that this is probably for people on the go, but at least having a voice telling you what you're doing and giving you tips would make this so much better. Also, don't just say "science". Tell us what kind of "science" and link us to specific research that maybe we want to know about.
- Gracana 12y agoThis is just the page for the exercise, the article (with link to the science) is here: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/
- webwielder 12y agoNothing beats working out to the 7 Minute Workout musical: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LezARmLDu6U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LezARmLDu6U
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- vlaube 12y agoI prefer my 7 Minute Workout Bash-Script: https://github.com/vlaube-de/7min-workout https://github.com/vlaube-de/7min-workout
- Opossum 12y agoLink to the original research article from ACSM: http://journals.lww.com/acsm-healthfitness/Fulltext/2013/05000/HIGH_INTENSITY_CIRCUIT_TRAINING_USING_BODY_WEIGHT_.5.aspx http://journals.lww.com/acsm-healthfitness/Fulltext/2013/050...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mparramon 12y agoI tried this about a year ago and blogged my results: http://www.developingandstuff.com/2013/09/50-days-of-scientific-7-minute-workout.html http://www.developingandstuff.com/2013/09/50-days-of-scienti...
- andyfleming 12y agoAnd here's the comments on that article on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6430619 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6430619
- wdewind 12y agoAre you still doing it? No offense but it doesn't seem to have had a tremendous effect besides making you feel better, which in and of itself may be totally worth it for 7 minutes of work anyway. Regardless, the only reason I say this is because I don't think that this is a good program, and I think the science around it is short sighted and not very well carried out. The major problem is that the studies are not nearly long enough. The human body can adapt really well, and these exercises don't really provide any meaningful level of progression (besides just doing them more). As a user of this program continues, they will have to keep adding cycles, and eventually they'll just be doing it an hour every morning. As a way to trick yourself into the habit of exercise I think that's great. But the concept that 7 minutes a day can really make you healthy is kind of absurd. There is no question it's better than nothing (especially for people who are already significantly overweight), but it's too bad it's not being sold as an intro to exercise program, rather than The Only Thing You Ever Have to Do Ever.
- mariodiana 12y ago> As a way to trick yourself into the habit of exercise [...] I heard something about this, only in the past few months, but I can't remember where. Apparently, the way to create habits is to trick yourself by doing something almost ridiculous or trivial. For example, say you want to start flossing regularly. For a lot of people, this is a tough thing to make a habit of. The suggestion is to just floss one tooth, once a day. Don't even try to floss two teeth the next day. Just keep flossing one tooth every day and try not to think about starting a flossing habit. And then, one day, so the suggestion goes, you'll just go ahead and spontaneously floss all of your teeth and continue to do so in the days after that. You've tricked yourself into the habit, because you had no conscious resistance to committing to flossing one tooth; and in the meantime, by flossing that one tooth, your subconscious built the habit. Once the habit was firmly in place, your conscious brain no longer had any resistance to put up. Something along those lines is supposed to work for exercise, and many other things as well.
- yabatopia 12y agoIf I remember correctly from a BBC documentary it's important to have a warm up session first before you do an intense workout like this, especially when you're just starting out. You don't want to risk injuries. Be nice to your muscles, tensons and joints: damage can be permanent, I know from experience.
- droopyEyelids 12y agoPart of the genius of this workout is that it's not throwing you into a position to injure yourself, all the vigorous motions are aerobic and the strenuous exercises are isometric.
- mattfrommars 12y agoSo how do I start with the warm up at home? I did notice when doing squats, I could hear some random noise coming from my knees.
- lingben 12y agowhat?! unless you're really in top shape and have done a lot of leg conditioning and weight lifting there is NO WAY that you can do a wall sit for 30 seconds straight! most people, even in good shape (not overweight or obese) can only do 10-15 seconds before their quads burn into a cinder try it! its a good exercise but 30 seconds? c'mon! also, another reason why this suggested 30 seconds duration is bad is that it will mean that most people who do try to meet the unrealistic 30 second duration will collapse down as their legs give out and this is NOT what you want to happen because risk of injury from this exercise is greatly increased if you don't get out of the position by standing up
- MichaelDickens 12y agoI could do a wall sit for about 45 seconds before I ever did any leg work.
- nkozyra 12y agoYeah I have to concur here, this should be totally feasible for a beginner.
- bthornbury 12y agoI can't tell if you're serious. I've done 10 minute wall sits when I was training. Anybody should be able to do 30 seconds.
- olympus 12y agoNo. Someone who can hold a wall sit for 30 seconds is hardly in "top shape." The recommended ability to start the P90X workout program is at least 1 minute (and that is considered a bare minimum to be able to do the workouts), and my 54 year old mom did that on the first try. If you are having a hard time with 30 seconds, I recommend scaling down the time, but working your way up as you get better. You can safely get out of the position by letting your butt go down to the ground, put a pillow/cushion underneath you if you are worried. P.S. As a military academy graduate I can tell you that 30 seconds is chump change; 5+ minutes gets you into "top shape" territory where people are collapsing, and pretty much any freshman at West Point, Annapolis, or the AFA can do 3+ minutes.
- MisterMashable 12y agoI wonder, what is the ratio of exercise programs articles vs. people who actually follow them?
- jordanpg 12y agoMy reaction to this is similar to this one: http://norvig.com/21-days.html http://norvig.com/21-days.html (Teach Yourself Programming in Ten Years) I've been exercising regularly for a long time and know pretty well what my "equilibrium" exercise time is, and it's about 5 - 6 times longer than 7 minutes. If I thought it could be shorter, then I would make it shorter because my #1 goal is to minimize the number of minutes of my life I spend on exercise. All I can say about this is that 7 minutes strains credulity and sounds like marketing nonsense to me. At a very minimum, I need to sustain an elevated heart rate for a few minutes to feel good.
- judk 12y agoWhy not make exercise more fun instead? Play a sport, bike instead of car, etc...
- ghshephard 12y agoThe difference between exercise/sports and training is the goal of getting the most amount of measurable impact towards a specific set of goals with the least amount of effort and time invested. It may be the case that playing sports (particularly soccer) will yield some progress towards your targets, but that will be with greatly reduced efficiency than if you put focussed effort to specific goals.
- pingswept 12y agoIf it makes you feel better, each hour you spend exercising extends your life by around 3.5 hours (net 2.5 after the hour you spent) on average. These are just rough numbers, backed up by the Framingham heart study and an analysis of the Framingham data by Jonker, et al.: http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/29/1/38.full.pdf http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/29/1/38.full.pdf They say 2.5 hours per week over a 75 year lifetime makes you live 3.5 years longer, and 2.5 hours per week over 75 years is around 1 year. (Of course, you might get hit by a bus tomorrow, but that's true whether you exercise or not. I guess you should avoid exercising near traffic.)
- 12y ago
- jamesaguilar 12y agoI tried the seven minute workout for a little while and saw no improvement in any dimension. This[1], on the other hand, has gotten me some significant results so far, five months in. [1] http://stronglifts.com/ http://stronglifts.com/
- melling 12y agoI find it hard to believe that you can do squats more than one day a week. It takes a while for large muscles to recover, especially when you're doing heavy weight.
- KobaQ 12y agoThen you've done it too hard. Ideally one should work-out at an intensity and volume (reps) that allows to be recovered after round about 48 hours. If the training is too hard compared to the fitness level you miss the point of supercompensation for the next training session. So, you have to build the ability to train hard up.
- speedyapoc 12y agoThe first few workouts are tough. As a beginner I could squat heavy 3x a week for the first 6ish months, increasing weight per workout. Now it's 2 days heavy and 1 day light.
- wdewind 12y agoThere are many advanced programs that squat heavy as possible every workout. Look at some of the Average Broz programming.
- brandonmenc 12y agoJust about every powerlifting or strength/mass program, from novice to expert, has multiple squat days a week. The theory is that because the large areas (ex: leg, back) are actually composed of many muscles, you can hit them more frequently with slight variations (working different parts/ranges/etc.) and still recover.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- adwf 12y ago12 exercises in 7 minutes seems a little rapid. I usually manage 4-5 in 30-45 minutes... I guess if you're beginning from a very sedentary level, this is probably a great starting point. It exercises most major muscle groups and will at least activate them far more than just sitting in an office chair.
- speedyapoc 12y agoNote that this "workout" isn't going to put on much (if any) muscle mass nor will it help you lose significant weight. Resistance training and diet is required for the former and diet is absolutely everything for the latter.
- gnah 12y agoI should be able to do better than this. Presenting The Broscientific 7-Minute Workout: A: 5x Back Squat 5x Weighted Chin-up or Barbell Row B: 5x Deadlift 5x Olympic Press Repeat alternating. Do as many warm up singles as you can fit (max 5) ascending in weight before each heavy set. Increase weight on every exercise as often and as much as possible. Get or make some micro plates to extend linear progress when you can no longer sustain 5lb jumps. If you have a few minutes extra, throw in an extra set of as many reps as you can comfortably do with 70% of the working weight on each exercise. If you can't do these movements spend 7 minutes a day learning form and improving mobility until you can.
- glibgil 12y agoYour workout costs money. The other workout is free.
- KobaQ 12y agoTrue, but the other has no effect for people with an average fitness level. It lacks intensity.
- judk 12y agoPeople who work out less than 6 minutes per day are all below average fitness level.
- gnah 12y agoConsider the audience. For an overweight person who only walks to their car and back the routine in the article could get them to a meager level of fitness. For someone who walks or bicycles for any of their transportation or for pleasure it won't have any effect. As a European this is most people I know.
- ghshephard 12y agoThe nyt article is pretty high intensity - walking alone (i speak as one who walks everywhere) doesn't get your heart rate racing unless you really put some effort into it, and certainly doesn't stress any muscle groups. Your average sedentary individual would not be able to complete the 7 minute workout. If they were signicantly overweight they would likely collapse 2 minutes into it. The goal of this type of training is to yield the greatest amount of impact with the least amount of effort in the shortest amount of time. Anybody who did the nyt 7 minute exercise at max intensity for a couple months is going to be in good shape. Do it everyday for 6 months and they will be in the 90th percentile of physical fitness in the United States for their age group. Which I think is a pretty good return for 7 minutes out if your day with no equipment other than a chair.
- danieltillett 12y agoI managed to develop a 5 minute workout that performs remarkable well for the time involved (it is not a pleasant 5 minutes though). The basis routine is 30 seconds absolutely flat out on an exercise bike cranked right up, then 30 seconds slow recovery. I do this first thing in the morning (before having a shower) and after fasting for at least 12 hours. I then don’t eat for 3 hours afterwards. It works remarkable well to keep me fitish (basically fit enough to do all the other physical activities I want to do) and at keeping my weight down. I find that this intense exercise makes me feel sick afterwards. This takes away my hunger until a few hours later so it is not too difficult to avoid eating for the 3 hours.
- alexnewman 12y agoThat's amazing. Why?
- danieltillett 12y agoI am not sure of what “why" you are asking about, but my aim was to find the exercise routine that took the least amount of time and still achieved the desired result. 5 round of 30s flat out is enough to get my heart rate up to its maximum and this seems to be all you need to do to increase your fitness - at least to the moderate levels I want. In regards the fasting and not eating afterwards there is some scientific literature that exercise after 12 hours of fasting followed by no eating for 3 does helps in weight loss. I can’t say if this is true or not, but doing intense exercise does reduce my appetite for quite a while afterwards. By doing this I can avoid eating for around 15 hours a day which doesn’t leave that much time for me to eat too much.
- mattfrommars 12y agoDo you fast 12 hour straight or do you break every 3 hours? I'm thinking of fasting too to keep my weight down but don't know what routine to follow
- danieltillett 12y agoWell the 12 hour fast is basically from dinner the night before until morning the next day. This fasting is easy as most of the time I am asleep :) The 3 hour fast afterwards is remarkably easy. I start to get hungry around 9.30am to 10.00am (around 2.5 hours in), but as I am usually hard at work at this time it is not too hard to resist eating until 10.30am. Other than this I eat whatever I like when I like. One of the good things of this program is I only need one shower and I can cool down under warm water saving even more time. Most short exercise programs are much longer once you add in all the ancillary activities like changing clothes and showering - mine really is 5 minutes only.
- kolev 12y agoThe true scientific one is called Body by Science [1]. If you have 100 minutes, invest watching this [2] from God himself (Doug McGuff M.D.). P.S. The next The 21 Convention will be in January 2015 [3]. [1] http://www.bodybyscience.net/ http://www.bodybyscience.net/ [2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PdJFbjWHEU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PdJFbjWHEU [3] http://www.the21convention.com/ http://www.the21convention.com/
- cwilson 12y agoThe 7 minute workout is for people who want to feel like they are working out with minimal effort. It's kind of ridiculous. I tried this for a few weeks 4 times a week and saw/felt almost no benefit. Then I upped it to a 30 minute workout using the same set of exercises and saw quite a bit of progress. That's really the difference. You need your heart-rate pumping for 30 minutes to really see benefits from this, not for 7 minutes. I doubt any "scientific" claims that 7 minutes a few times a week is all the exercise someone needs. At the very least double it. Do 14 minutes. I remember trying this while out of shape (hadn't done any intense exercise in months) and with 7 minutes I barely broke a sweat. Unless you're morbidly obese you need to do more than this. If you really want a god exercise buy some weights or go to the gym. Moving around really heavy objects for 30 - 45 minutes is the best bang for your buck workout you can get.
- agumonkey 12y agoHow much of this is boot overhead ? maybe with time people can reach 30min level of changes in a focused 7min.
- cwilson 12y agoAgain, the only people 7 minutes of essentially cardio is going to benefit are people who are insanely out of shape. The second you're just in "ok" shape is the second 7 minutes is basically worthless to to you. I really hate that this 7 minute workout thing is becoming a trend. It's misleading in its benefits. If everyone writing or talking about it wants to clarify and say it's only beneficial for people who are dangerously out of shape, fine, but otherwise it's stupid. Workout for 30 minutes. Please.
- GFischer 12y agoWell, I'm extremely out of shape, and I don't make time for workouts in my schedule. However, my resistante is to get started ("boot time"), once I'm dressed for a workout (that is, not in a suit or jeans), 7 minutes or 14 or even maybe 30 is not that much of a difference.
- 12y ago
- throwawayme 12y agoWhole lotta "I'm fit and this did nothing after 3 days. All I had to do was go to a gym and workout for an hour every day, and then I saw gains" You're dubasses, all of you.
- hunvreus 12y agoTo anybody trying to get back in shape, I can't recommend Nerd Fitness (http://www.nerdfitness.com/ http://www.nerdfitness.com/) enough. I used it to get back in shape 2 or 3 years ago, it's very approachable even with no real fitness knowledge. I am not affiliated. Bottom line though: - Fix your diet (whatever works for you, for me it was getting rid of carbs), - Make time for this and build up the routine (I get most of my workouts done in under 35 minutes all included, I do this at least 3 times a week), - You don't need a gym; you can get dumbbells for cheap, but even without it there is a lot you can do (I haven't lifted anything in a year, doing mostly bodyweight).
- parkaboy 12y agoSince we're all tossing our favorite regimens into the ring, I've been using bodyweight training site http://fitloop.co http://fitloop.co (free site made by one of the members of r/bodyweightfitness) for 5 months now, and the progress has been pretty amazing. A good diet is important too, of course.
- patrickg_zill 12y agoThe old Canadian RAF exercise program 5BX worked reasonably well for me when I did it. I got as far as the highest level, "A" on Chart 5 I think. Chart 6 is marked as "only champion athletes can do this" and I couldn't even finish the lowest level on that chart no matter how hard I tried. The most famous adherent is/was probably the writer Tom Clancy.