2 ms·
The game would be pretty boring if the best team always won. It's a game, it's meant for fun, it's not a science experiment. By having it semi-random, you spr
by ars 17y ago
The game would be pretty boring if the best team always won.
It's a game, it's meant for fun, it's not a science experiment.
By having it semi-random, you spread out then ups and downs.
Someone did an analysis of video games (posted on slashdot, but I can't find it), where they showed that the best video games don't have solid excitement all the way, but rather ups and downs.
The same it true here. If your team always won you would be bored pretty quickly.
- mechanical_fish 17y agoThe game would be pretty boring if the best team always won. Indeed, as many sports folks have pointed out, one of the most popular annual sporting events in the USA is the NCAA college basketball tournament. A single-elimination event which is pretty much designed to improve the odds of having the "best" team get accidentally disqualified by an improbable fluke. The winner must win six consecutive games, while under enormous pressure, without making a mistake. As it happens, the distribution of talent in college basketball still makes the seedings work fairly well. Just as World Cup soccer seedings work decently well, though it too becomes a single-elimination tournament after the first round. But these tournaments could obviously be much better designed if the objective was science.