4 ms·
'It bans "unreasonable" searches and seizures without a warrant.' It bans unreasonable searches and seizures, period. Hopefully, a warrant will only be issued
by dllthomas 12y ago
'It bans "unreasonable" searches and seizures without a warrant.'
It bans unreasonable searches and seizures, period.
Hopefully, a warrant will only be issued when the search is reasonable, and a search with more oversight and checks will be more reasonable than the same search without.
- tptacek 12y agoThe Fourth Amendment does not demand a warrant for every search. Only on Internet message boards has this not been a settled issue since before our grandparents were all born. To understand why the Fourth Amendment governs both searches and warrants, it's helpful to read up on what a "General Warrant" was at the time of the founders. Hint: they often didn't really have much to do with generating evidence. The Amendment has two goals: first, to give the courts, rather than Congress or the President, authority in determining what a valid search is, and second to ensure that no branch of government could arbitrarily generate a piece of paper authorizing police to turn someone's house inside out.
- dllthomas 12y agoI think you misinterpreted me. I didn't say every search must have a warrant. I said every search must be reasonable, and that a warrant makes some otherwise-unreasonable searches reasonable.